4 ms·
The paper itself is a chuckle fest (as are many Intelligencer submissions) and concludes: > The goal here has been neither to challenge nor to confirm Darwin’s
by defrost 4y ago
The paper itself is a chuckle fest (as are many Intelligencer submissions) and concludes:
> The goal here has been neither to challenge nor to confirm Darwin’s and other researchers’ observations of greater male variability for any given species or any given trait, but rather to propose an elementary mathematical theory based on biological/evolutionary mechanisms that might serve as a starting point to help explain how one sex of a species might tend to evolve with greater variability than the other sex.
ie. Such a thing may or may not be true, but if it were true there is a pachinko machine that can create that effect.
Of course, more generally, if you posit a distribution, there exists a pachinko machine that can recreate it.
What's telling is that this paper appends two runs of empirical data sets:
A.1 Primary Research Studies Supporting the Greater Male Variability Hypothesis
and
A.2 Primary Research Studies Not Supporting the Greater Male Variability Hypothesis
so they're not even backing a horse in any race, just stirring the pot for a giggle .. via 30+ pages with references.
- AinderS 4y agoEverything is a chuckle if you replace phrases like "plausible evolutionary mechanism" with "pachinko machine".
- defrost 4y agoIt's a valid equivalence. The paper could equally describe an plausible evolutionary mechanism by which the male sex evolves to be tiny in comparison to females who consume them after snu-snu. While this has zero bearing on the reality of human evolution it has an example in nature in the spider kingdom.
- AinderS 4y ago> While this has zero bearing on the reality of human evolution It does have bearing. It is proof by example that biology and evolution does not rule out such a possibility. For the actual paper in question, it is proof that such an outcome is not (yet) ruled out even in the specific case of humans.
- defrost 4y agoThe possibilities are endless (albeit enumerable), sure - that's the chuckle - it's a given from the outset and flows from the axioms of the game. This paper doesn't take a broad view and show that many things are possible, it takes a narrow view and demonstrates that one specific thing (among many) is possible. ie. a dull trite result. The fact that many possiblies can follow from evolution does bring any specific light to bear on the actual extent reality of human evolution as it is today. The same arguments here that show it is possible for a mechanism of weights to favour more variation in males can equally be used to show that weights exist to favour more variation in females, or, as in the case of spider, that weights could exist to favor a size variation in which females dwarf males. Fascinating .. but an abstract result that sheds nothing on the current extant actuality.
- V-2 4y agoIt's a math paper, not one in evolutionary biology. Only the mathematical aspect is of relevance here, and either it holds water or it doesn't. You can assume a seven-dimensional space, and for analyzing the geometry of such space it is irrelevant whether it actually exists somewhere in the universe or beyond.
- civilized 4y agoHigh-energy physicists make up theories for the mechanisms behind phenomena that may or may not even exist all the time. One can question the utility of this but no one strings up such authors for heresy.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- willis936 4y agoTheoretical physics does not aim to influence social policy.
- zozbot234 4y agoThat's news to me. How do all those nifty particle accelerators get funded, then?
- willis936 4y agoThe budget is only loosely related to social policy. Social policy is related to who gets what rights and priveleges.
- rowanG077 4y agoAnd a group of physicist getting very expensive toys while the chemist/biologist/psychologist do not is exactly that. The physicist have rights and privileges the others don't have.
- feet 4y agoDoes this paper aim to influence policy?
- willis936 4y agoOf course. All anthropological work about contemporary society seeks to inform public opinion which dictates policy.
- RayVR 4y agouh...no. They are not stirring the pot. Proposing rigorous processes that approximate observed phenomena is a very common line of research. Many of the phenomena in financial markets that I cared about when I was trading had researchers coming up with models/modifying existing models to attempt to generate the same observed risk premia.