13 ms·
The author kinda touches on that with: > Another argument is that we know too little to analyze cells in the way engineers analyze their systems. But, the ques
by Terr_ 4y ago
The author kinda touches on that with:
> Another argument is that we know too little to analyze cells in the way engineers analyze their systems. But, the question is whether we would be able to understand what we need to learn if we do not use a formal description. The biochemists would measure rates and concentrations to understand how biochemical processes work. A discrepancy between the measured and calculated values would indicate a missing link and lead to the discovery of a new enzyme, and a better understanding of the subject of investigation.
> Do we know what to measure to understand a signal transduction pathway? Are we even convinced that we need to measure something? As Sydney Brenner noted, it seems that biochemistry disappeared in the same year as communism (Brenner, 1995
). I think that a formal description would make the need to measure a system's parameters obvious and would help to understand what these parameters are.
- joshuahedlund 4y agoMaybe it’s that I don’t grok what the author means by “formal description” but I don’t see how that really touches on it. As a layman the impression I got from the article is “biologists are doing the wrong things to learn about cells, I think they should be doing this other thing instead” whereas the impression I have from what I’ve read about those learning processes is that the learning is so hard that biologists are literally just doing whatever they can come up with to learn anything at all. They didn’t choose these processes because of what they wanted to learn, they literally invented those processes because it was what they could come up with (pretty ingeniously, too), there are no alternatives until those are invented and they would be ecstatic to use them as well. I probably have a disconnect from my lack of knowledge. An example would help; if it’s in the radio analogy I’ve lost it by the orders of magnitude difference in merely observing it at all.