3 ms·
> Simple test: will it hurt more _overall_ to suddenly lose them or keep them? So everything or nothing? Sounds like a false dilemma. Another problem with thi
by Terr_ 4y ago
> Simple test: will it hurt more _overall_ to suddenly lose them or keep them?
So everything or nothing? Sounds like a false dilemma.
Another problem with this decision-making approach is that anything can be un/justified simply by changing the unspoken timescale at which you measure outcomes.
On a short timescale, a knife stabbed into my gut should stay, because removing it will cause blood-loss.
However on a longer timescale where I'm in the hands of some doctors with bandages, it should absolutely be removed...
- aksss 4y agoNo, I think you’re missing the idea that this is a thought exercise to test the statement of police being “overall” bad.
- TomSwirly 4y agoYou live in a leaky tent with a lot of holes in it. Someone suggests you'd be better in a house. "Imagine where I would be without the tent! This is a thought experiment to test the statement of 'this tent being overall bad'. Therefore I won't move."