3 ms·
This seems manifestly unconstitutional. How long will this survive a 1A challenge?
by Waterluvian 4y ago
This seems manifestly unconstitutional. How long will this survive a 1A challenge?
- aksss 4y agoI think the idea of a line being drawn at interference is pretty well established and could see the 8-foot rule as trying to establish a useable standard. How does it apply in a traffic stop though? Not sure if there are conditions for the 8-foot rule described in the law. I could see it being allowable (or at least NOT presumptively unconstitutional) in the public setting of a sidewalk as pertaining to parties not directly involved in a matter. I am far more skeptical that it could apply to a person who is the direct subject of an interaction or a companion thereof.
- raziel2701 4y agoGiven that the Supreme Court we have today is now an extension of the Christian Taliban I'm not very hopeful we're in a time of fairness and justice.
- scoofy 4y agoThe new court has a general thesis on things that different from the previous court. They see to be extremely pro broad, written-in-text rights. I think it would be a huge surprise if they allowed something like this.
- scoofy 4y agoIt seems like it would be trivially unconstitutional, yes.