3 ms·
I've noted that many newspapers don't provide external links as a rule, though that reluctance seems to be slipping somewhat. Unfortunately, that's accompanied
by dredmorbius 4y ago
I've noted that many newspapers don't provide external links as a rule, though that reluctance seems to be slipping somewhat. Unfortunately, that's accompanied by an tendency for those external links to rot with extreme speed and prejudice, which ... might actually justify the reluctance.
Linking an archived copy of the content has merits, though increasing The Usual Suspect (the Internet Archive's Wayback Machine) itself has difficulty in preserving complex content. (The rather less transparent Archive.Today is often superior in quality if not necessarily in trust or reputation, and I say that relying on it heavily myself.)
I know that I've noted news organisations which do seem to link sources relatively freely, and thought I'd commented on it previously. I'm not finding any previous mentions by me here at HN (my usual personal quips trove, amongst other benefits). Though if memory serves, the New York Times tends not to provide links where it really ought to. I believe the Los Angeles Times might have a greater tendency to. Perhaps also NPR and/or The Guardian which I tend to rely on, though I'm not certain that's been my earlier observation.
In the 19th century and through a good part of the early 20th, newspapers would not only reference specific documents or speeches but publish them in whole. In large part, this is because that was the only way to distribute and reference the material. That practice has waned tremendously, and we often see material only through commentary and reference, rather than in original form. I've come to view this quite dimly.
I'm also fairly certain that copyright is a major consideration and factor here, and another way in which it's proving a disservice to the public good.
- kebman 4y agoCopyright shouldn't be a consideration for the press. Not when dealing with newsworthy items, anyway. When it comes to public resources and government, I see no reason to not just link the real thing. Instead I see outlets like Vox post articles titled, "Biden's executive order on abortion, briefly explained" and so on, where we'll just have to trust that what they say is indeed true. It most likely is, of course, or they'd make fools of themselves. But when it comes from Vox, or Fox, it almost always comes with a slant.
- dredmorbius 4y agoI hear you and I'd like to think that. For numerous reasons, it seems that there's an "is-ought" disconnect here, as is often the case. Business tends to be exceedingly spooked by risk, especially long-tail unconstrained risk. And copyright litigation presents an excellent example of same. There are also other concerns. In an era of physical print and shrinking "news holes", the actual textual content of newspapers tended to shrink, perhaps establishing a tradition of no longer printing speeches verbatim. With the attention economy of the Web, the risk of sending readers off-site is a concern I've heard voiced many times both in print and public discussions and privately amongst people I know in the press. It's quite unfortunate, but real. The case of US Government documents, in which there is no copyright concern is especially inexcusable. I'd agree with you strongly there. Increasingly when I find such an opinion piece, regardless of the publication, I look for the source document and try to read it first. (I don't always follow through, but it is if nothing else an aspirational goal.)