3 ms·
If you don't trust the warnings of the people who made the model, why do you trust their model? They also made this nice interactive animation to demonstrate t
by ZeroGravitas 4y ago
If you don't trust the warnings of the people who made the model, why do you trust their model?
They also made this nice interactive animation to demonstrate the impact of cross border flows:
https://viz.japangrid.researchvitae.com/pypsa-eur-animation/ https://viz.japangrid.researchvitae.com/pypsa-eur-animation/
- kragen 4y agoWhat makes you think pfdietz doesn't trust the warnings of the people who made the model?
- ZeroGravitas 4y agopfdietz said, long term storage is necessary if you want a 100% renewable grid, replying to me saying it's not necessary (though there's some potential confusion around whether responsive demand to make green hydrogen counts as long term storage or not). Someone else said, that's a big if, since 99% renewable is probably much cheaper. When they said you can try it yourself, I thought they were disagreeing with that point, which I, and the people who made the model, agree with. (As another example, the current US strategy is to get to 95% low carbon electricity and then shift focus to electrifying more things, as that has a bigger impact on carbon at that point, and helps to absorb variability.) Now, I'm not sure what point they were making.
- pfdietz 4y agoThe ironic thing here is that if you take that model, and play with it as I suggested, it would validate the earlier claim that long term storage is really just useful for the last percent or so. It's there to cover the "black swan" events when renewables are out for an extended period. (Well, not quite, because it ignores seasonality of demand, and if that's out of sync with seasonality of supply then more long term storage might be useful.) Sure, the model is wrong. All models are wrong, but some are useful.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoSo in the model, long term storage is only required for the last 1% or so. And the model makers mention a list of things, like interconnects and waste to energy that are not included in the model, and that would further reduce that need, so I feel the model supports my claim that long term storage isn't required, but I think you disagree. One thing they didn't include in the model, but do mention is the electrification of other sectors, which would require a lot of green hydrogen to be produced. This increases the electricity generated, and also introduces a big modulatable load, which means more hydrogen would be 'stored' but less would need to be burned, which then makes it ambigous if that actually counts as storage, particularly as you could choose to burn it if necessary but then use it for other puproses, like fertilizer, if you didn't need it. I see green hydrogen as the main marketplace competitor to long term storage, so this distinction is important in my view.