2 ms·
Your analogy doesn’t adhere to the bounds proscribed by this new law: if the officer has a legitimate reason to believe the other person is an accomplice in the
by woodruffw 4y ago
Your analogy doesn’t adhere to the bounds proscribed by this new law: if the officer has a legitimate reason to believe the other person is an accomplice in the crime, then they’re involved in the “law enforcement operation” and the recording law doesn’t apply to them.
This is bad law: it takes a set of restrictions that already exist, and adds additional language to them in order to chill civic participation. The police already have a cornucopia of powers available to them; they don’t need a completely arbitrary carve-out for just the act of recording their actions.
- frognumber 4y agoI think, in the situation I gave, there isn't legitimate reason to believe either way. All you know is you're holding down a suspect who has a knife, and their brother is walking up awfully close up to you. You don't know if they're: 1. About to smack you in the head to save their brother 2. Trying to make a nice video recording Adrenaline is flowing, and you have 1.5 seconds to decide. Which way do you guess? The law seems reasonable in concept. Lots of flaws in the language, as is being pointed out in this discussion (although sometimes incorrectly). What bugs me most is: "C. this section does not establish a right or authorize any person to make a video recording of law enforcement activity."