3 ms·
Why have traditional taxi companies when evidently just having some computers in the cloud can do the same thing for basically free and let the drivers take all
by Jensson 4y ago
Why have traditional taxi companies when evidently just having some computers in the cloud can do the same thing for basically free and let the drivers take all the profit? I don't like Uber as a company, but I don't see why we can't have similar services around or why it is wrong to try to change laws to make such services legal?
- mantas 4y agoSomebody has to run those „computers in the cloud“. Government-appointed monopoly? Government itself? Which would be interesting, but there could be so many opportunities for corruption...
- Jensson 4y agoThe government can run postal services and has done that for centuries, I don't see why they couldn't run this as well. As soon as a reasonable matching algorithm matching driver and passenger is open to the public everyone could easily deploy this wherever they want. Governments aren't good at innovating, but they are great at keeping stable systems running.
- dewey 4y agoI somehow have the feeling that trusting multiple smaller companies with the trip data is a lot better than having a central authority, which is also the government owning all that data in one place.
- Jensson 4y agoGovernment already runs healthcare, public transit, the telephone net, post etc, what difference does this make? If they want your location data they already got it from your phones network connection. Alternatively they could just regulate the field and set a cap on how much the rideshare app provider can take, ensuring that drivers get most of it and the provider just gets enough to keep the service running. Lots of fields are regulated this way, the important part here is that automation profits shouldn't all end up at a few huge corporations but instead get distributed to the workers.
- mantas 4y agoIn many cases it's single-payer rather than government-run.
- mantas 4y ago... and other parcel companies run loops around oldschool postal services now. Coming up with a reasonable matching algorithm would be innovation too in a sense. I doubt current matching algorithms are optimised for anything but operator's profit.
- dewey 4y agoIt's not only about the "computer" or the software running the matching of passengers to drivers. It's about more boring topics like passenger safety, insurances and education.
- mytailorisrich 4y agoInsurance is compulsory just to drive a car, passenger safety is resolved with the right checks. Both of which a trivial licensing issues. The point, certainly in France since Macron is prominently mentioned, is that traditional taxis are a heavily restrictive corporation. Number of licenses is very limited and they fetch 100k+ euros because drivers can sell their on when they leave the business. Traditionally they obviously only accept cash, fares are expensive, they charge extra by weight for luggage in the boot, phone booking only, etc. None of this is in the interests of consumers and Macron wanted to open up the industry. Like it or not, I think Uber provided the long overdue "kick in the butt" that the taxi industry needed in many countries.
- dewey 4y ago> Insurance is compulsory just to drive a car There's a difference between the regular insurance you have to have for driving a car in most countries and the insurance for transporting people for profit. > passenger safety is resolved with the right checks. Both of which a trivial licensing issues. As it turns out this was not as "trival" as all the startups in this space thought when they bypassed regulation at the beginning.
- mytailorisrich 4y agoOf course there is a difference, but it's trivial and irrelevant. Likewise for safety. If a company/driver operates without a license then it is an issue for the enforcement authority, Uber or no Uber. Again, ultimately the industry needed a kick in the butt and Uber provided it.