6 ms·
That's a pretty big if. Most people would be ecstatic if the grid was 99% decarbonized, and 99% decarbonized is probably an order of magnitude easier than 100
by bryanlarsen 4y ago
That's a pretty big if. Most people would be ecstatic if the grid was 99% decarbonized, and 99% decarbonized is probably an order of magnitude easier than 100% decarbonized. Unless you're some place like British Columbia with massive hydro reserves.
- pfdietz 4y agoYou can try for yourself at https://model.energy/ https://model.energy/ If you add "Dispatchable 1", which is gas, and give it zero cost, but then put a limit on the total CO2 emission, you can get the optimal setup to get X% (X < 100) of a synthetic baseload source from wind/solar/batteries/hydrogen. Then take out hydrogen and look at the cost difference.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agohttps://model.energy/#background-and-warnings https://model.energy/#background-and-warnings The first 4 items are relevant here: > Electricity systems with zero direct CO2 emissions can be built more cheaply by using additional technology options. The examples here are simply a toy model to put an upper bound on the costs for a very simple setup. Additional generation technologies which may reduce costs include using existing hydroelectric generators, biomass from sustainable resources (such as waste and agricultural/forestry residues), offshore wind, concentrating solar thermal, geothermal, ocean energy, nuclear and fossil/biomass plants with CCS. Two additional dispatchable technologies are provided under "advanced assumption settings". Additional storage technologies include redox flow batteries, compressed air energy storage, etc. Other options include allowing demand to adapt to renewable profiles (demand-side management). > No import or export capacities with other regions are assumed, so each region must meet the baseload profile by itself. Existing and planned transmission grid connections between regions can reduce costs by up to 20% by smoothing wind over a continent-sized area (see e.g. this paper or this one). > Including energy demand sectors other than electricity, like transport, heating and non-electric industrial demand can offer additional flexibility (e.g. load-shifting by battery electric vehicles and thermal storage for electrified heating), see e.g. this paper or this one. > Costs here are for completely decarbonised electricity systems. Reaching lower levels of decarbonisation is much cheaper and doesn't necessarily require any storage at all. A non-zero carbon dioxide emission target and options for fossil-fuelled generators can be set under "advanced assumption settings".
- pfdietz 4y agoI'm open to you showing me a more detailed model that comes to a different conclusion, but you will have to show me that model.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoIf you don't trust the warnings of the people who made the model, why do you trust their model? They also made this nice interactive animation to demonstrate the impact of cross border flows: https://viz.japangrid.researchvitae.com/pypsa-eur-animation/ https://viz.japangrid.researchvitae.com/pypsa-eur-animation/
- kragen 4y agoWhat makes you think pfdietz doesn't trust the warnings of the people who made the model?
- ZeroGravitas 4y agopfdietz said, long term storage is necessary if you want a 100% renewable grid, replying to me saying it's not necessary (though there's some potential confusion around whether responsive demand to make green hydrogen counts as long term storage or not). Someone else said, that's a big if, since 99% renewable is probably much cheaper. When they said you can try it yourself, I thought they were disagreeing with that point, which I, and the people who made the model, agree with. (As another example, the current US strategy is to get to 95% low carbon electricity and then shift focus to electrifying more things, as that has a bigger impact on carbon at that point, and helps to absorb variability.) Now, I'm not sure what point they were making.
- pfdietz 4y agoThe ironic thing here is that if you take that model, and play with it as I suggested, it would validate the earlier claim that long term storage is really just useful for the last percent or so. It's there to cover the "black swan" events when renewables are out for an extended period. (Well, not quite, because it ignores seasonality of demand, and if that's out of sync with seasonality of supply then more long term storage might be useful.) Sure, the model is wrong. All models are wrong, but some are useful.