4 ms·
Why can't well funded researchers just assign a post-doc to go through all the papers and analyze their sentiments? Doesn't seem so difficult logistically or te
by MichaelZuo 4y ago
Why can't well funded researchers just assign a post-doc to go through all the papers and analyze their sentiments?
Doesn't seem so difficult logistically or technically.
- nixpulvis 4y agoHow do you control for bias in the post-doc? What exactly is "sentiment"? Is it a qualitative description, or something more analytical? Why does a future researcher care about the sentiment instead of the content itself? Or is this to better help guide other research directions?
- MichaelZuo 4y agoAs it becomes more common you could pool together the results of the sentimental analysis and try to find common agreement among dozens or hundreds. Presumably that would be close to an unbiased look. It would be helpful in the ways expressed in the article, i.e. to allow current and future researchers to see if highly cited papers are actually expressing near complete agreement or near complete disagreement, or a mixed viewpoint, at a quick glance.
- bee_rider 4y agoSeems like a good project for an undergrad who is just getting started in research, actually.
- jpeloquin 4y agoWe just call this "literature review", and everyone does it at times regardless of seniority level. But the aim is not a sentiment graph because it doesn't really matter whether author A said paper B was good or bad. What would we even use that information for? We instead want a comprehensive list of papers that are relevant to what we're trying to do right now, with a note on each saying why it is relevant.