5 ms·
How is this anything other than an attempt to keep people from collecting evidence of bad police behavior? Now that a large majority of people have a high qual
by bediger4000 4y ago
How is this anything other than an attempt to keep people from collecting evidence of bad police behavior?
Now that a large majority of people have a high quality video camera in their pockets, we've learned 2 things: (1) alien abduction was not real (2) police very deliberately kill members of racial minorities. I think this law is a reaction to (2).
- UIUC_06 4y ago
- elmerfud 4y agoYou need to read the law to understand it better and also understand the current rulings that courts have provided on filming police. This law is none of those things that you state it's simply codifying a distance for what the courts have already upheld that police can do. If you are party to the police interaction you can film closer than 8 ft. If you are in a car as a passenger you can film the interaction and the police cannot ask you to stop. If you are a non-party person simply watching the interaction the police can now ask you to maintain a distance of 8 ft. Courts have already upheld routinely that police can ask people who are not party to the interaction to step away and they can create a reasonable area around them and the scene and keep people out of it. The definition of reasonable area varies based upon the situation. This that a reasonable area is a minimum of 8 ft. There are situations where that distance may be greater. Regardless of what you think of the police they do need to be empowered to keep bystanders out of the middle of an interaction with their cameras in order to conduct their duties. 8 ft for a bystander is a very reasonable distance. At 8 ft your camera can see anything that a human-sized person is doing it to another human-sized person and it can record the audio of that interaction as well at 8 ft. And as always the person who is party to the interaction can record the interaction and this is codified in this law as well. Laws like this do more to uphold a citizens ability to record the police then it does to take it away. Any reasonable person would understand that because without a law like this the police could argue that 50 ft is a reasonable distance. Now we have a law that says 8 ft is a reasonable distance in Arizona.
- watwut 4y agoPolice can tell you to step away whether you are holding the camera or not. The thing this does is that people who are close to what is actually happening will be scared to take camera and start filming. And if they do, the cops will be able to harass them.
- account-5 4y agoThanks for the calm and reasonable response. Some of the comments here make me wonder how close people want to be to an ongoing incident? Inches? A foot? At a certain distance you're just in the way, 8 feet seems completely acceptable. Police are able to do their job without obstruction from onlookers, onlockers are close enough to see/record the police doing their job.
- staticassertion 4y agoAs close as I want to be, if it's a public space.
- account-5 4y agoMaybe you could get a piggyback from the cops while they're dealing with something?
- staticassertion 4y agoThat would be assault.
- plandis 4y agoThis law only serves to tell police how close they need to move towards people filming in order to get them to stop so their abuses can be done without being recorded.
- ksaj 4y agoI think an officer approaching you makes you party to the interaction. I wouldn't shut mine off in this case, and I'd happily face court if an officer approached me while simultaneously claiming I'm not party to the interaction. The officer's approach to my person is the only the interaction I'm videoing at that moment. Anything else is incidental.
- fortran77 4y agoPolice kill way too many people. Whether there's a racial motivation or basis behind that cannot usually be determined by selectively watching videos. And scholarly sources have published studies that show the answer is complicated: see https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-020-01846-z https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-020-01846-z and https://www.manhattan-institute.org/verbruggen-fatal-police-shootings https://www.manhattan-institute.org/verbruggen-fatal-police-... for two different takes on ths.
- recyclelater 4y agoThere are roughly 350 million people in this country. It’s surprising the number of people killed by police isn’t higher. Everyone contextualizes police shootings as if they all happen in their local city, so the numbers seem large. I want this number as small as possible while not over correcting so much that we have other negative consequences (violent crime increases).
- ivalm 4y agoPer capita we are (edit: #33) in the world and are an absolute leader among developed countries [0] [0] https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/police-killings-by-country https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/police-ki...
- delecti 4y agoWe're #7 by count, not per-capita. Per-capita we're #33 (scroll down to the chart sorted by "per 10m"). Though our per capita rate is still absurd compared to other developed countries. The next comparable country is Canada at 9.7, 1/3 as high.
- ivalm 4y agoYou’re right!
- recyclelater 4y ago
- ddingus 4y agoI DO NOT agree with the other comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32046231 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32046231 deleted! And boy did I have this wrong!! (This comment has been edited to show the text, and where I was in error!) Here's the text: ARIZONA HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES Fifty-fifth Legislature Second Regular Session House: APPROP DPA 7-5-0-1 HB 2319: law enforcement activity; recording prohibition Sponsor: Representative Kavanagh, LD 23 House Engrossed Overview Outlines regulations for a person making a video recording (recording) of a law enforcement activity (activity). History Provisions 1. States that it is unlawful for a person to knowingly make a recording within eight feet of an activity and without the permission of a law enforcement officer (LEO). (Sec. 1) 2. Directs that for an activity occurring inside a closed structure on private property, a person authorized to be on the private property may make a video recording of the activity from an adjacent room that is less than eight feet away from the activity. (Sec. 1) 3. States a person may not make a video recording of an activity from within eight feet of an activity inside a closed structure on private property if the LEO determines the person is interfering with the activity or that is it not safe to be in the area. (Sec. 1) 4. Provides that a person who is the subject of the police contact may make a recording if doing so does not interfere with lawful police actions. (Sec. 1) 5. Asserts these provisions do not establish a right or authorize any person to make a video recording of an activity. (Sec. 1) 6. Classifies unlawfully recording an activity as a petty offense. (Sec. 1) 7. Classifies failing to comply with LEO verbal warnings regarding recording an activity or if the person has been previously convicted of unlawfully recording an activity as a class 3 misdemeanor (Sec. 1) Statute prohibits a person from obstructing governmental operations. A person commits obstructing governmental operations when the person uses threats or violence to hinder a peace officer from enforcing the law or acting under official authority. This offense is classified as a class 1 misdemeanor (A.R.S. 13-2402). 8. Defines law enforcement activity. (Sec. 1) Prop 105 (45 votes) Prop 108 (40 votes) Emergency (40 votes) Initials FK Page 1 Fiscal Note HB 2319 House Engrossed >and without the permission of a law enforcement officer (LEO). (Sec. 1) That language is not in the stories talking about the bill, and said language is not in line with the First Amendment.
- mlyle 4y agoI'm not sure why you think this law explicitly allows people to be 8' away and film. Instead, it criminalizes being closer than 8' and filming, while not superseding other laws that could be used to harass or prevent recording. An explicit codification of the right to record and circumstances when it applies could be part of a decent compromise here, but this legislation isn't it.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- markovbot 4y agoThis is pretty transparently a law to keep people from collecting evidence of bad police behavior. There's been entirely too much of that and people are starting to question the unaccountable armed gangs that roam our cities. To fix people noticing that this might be bad, Arizona is enacting laws to ensure the police can continue to brutalize without repercussions. It's unfortunate that this thread is full of bootlickers doing mental gymnastics to justify what is clearly an unjust law, but this is HN after all
- UIUC_06 4y ago> police very deliberately kill members of racial minorities This is an inflammatory statement which demands some evidence. "Very deliberately" implies a knowledge of police state of mind. Do you have such knowledge? AFAIK, studies of police shootings are pretty inconclusive in that respect. Do you have support for your statement?