4 ms·
A number of my blog posts over the years have hit #1 on HN. I've noticed that HN commenters are more likely to follow the "guidelines" with each other than with
by lapcat 4y ago
A number of my blog posts over the years have hit #1 on HN. I've noticed that HN commenters are more likely to follow the "guidelines" with each other than with the article author. Too often, the author is treated uncharitably, with contempt and/or ridicule.
I've spoken to dang personally about this at some length, but I wasn't really satisfied with his response, which was more or less a denial of the problem, or at least a refusal to do anything about it. Honestly, I've occasionally thought of blacklisting HN referrers from my web server, though I've never gone through with such a drastic measure.
I've found that the best way to handle it is to take matters into my own hands, create an account here, and reply in the comments. I can clarify my points and shoot down uncharitable reactions. It's a shame that authors have to self-manage the responses though. Left to themselves, HN commenters often becomes vicious wolves. I would say that the HN guidelines are worthless if the same respect isn't given to the article authors.
- boxmonster 4y ago
- lapcat 4y agoThank you for so helpfully illustrating the phenomenon that everyone is discussing here.
- boxmonster 4y ago"If you can't stand the heat, stay out of the kitchen" - Harry S. Truman There is nothing wrong with my comment. I am of the opinion that you wasted dang's time, especially since recently we have all been praising him for his very hard work running this site, for which you seem entirely ungrateful for. Where did you get the idea that the world has to agree with your opinions?
- lapcat 4y agoThis is again a very uncharitable reading of my comment. I urge you to read https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html again. To clarify: 1) There is a literally a "Contact" mailto: link at the bottom of this page, so I don't know why one has to be "self-important" to contact the moderator. 2) The phrase "at some length" was meant to imply something less than "at length". It was a serious conversation, but I don't recall it continuing particularly long. [EDIT: Searching my email archive, I found that the thread was only a few emails, so "at some length" may itself be a bit of an exaggeration.] 3) I appreciate that dang replied, but that doesn't mean we came to an agreement on the matter. Where did you get the idea that I had to agree with dang's opinions? In any case, I don't see how I "wasted" his time at all, when he voluntarily replied and talked with me about an ongoing HN issue. Dang is responsible for his own choices and for managing his own time.