5 ms·
"Why the Japanese media has refused to identify the “religious group” that formed the motive for the killing must remain as speculation at this juncture, though
by giantg2 4y ago
"Why the Japanese media has refused to identify the “religious group” that formed the motive for the killing must remain as speculation at this juncture, though it reflects very poorly on Japan’s status as a democratic nation."
Because they aren't stupid. When you name names and provide ample details you have given the killer things that encourage others - infamy, a platform to spread their message, etc.
In the US, we know that providing these details, such as the killer's name, and even the media's hyper focus on the event contribute to copy cats.
Why don't we create a law to prevent the media from naming names of mass killers or assassins and giving them a platform? After all, we know that this will save lives.
Edit: why disagree without reply? No right is absolute. There are already restrictions on speech, and that same reasoning is what allows gun control.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5296697/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5296697/
- andrew_ 4y agoMy guess as to why you're not getting replies because the content of your comment is highly polarizing, contains assertions as absolutes rather than points of debate, and would likely result in camp vs. camp which will play out ad infinitum.
- giantg2 4y agoI can see that the topic is generally polarizing and that my first sentence is assuming and could be better. I do ask a question of why we don't have a law (or really just have people sue over the coverage contributing to the act). The part about knowing that sensationalized and detailed reports contributes is a pretty solid fact (theory, analysis, and anecdotal admissions from copycats).
- 15155 4y agoPen the statue for us, what would one look like that would stop this type of release of names?
- giantg2 4y agoIf you read the study, there is a link to the FBI guidelines. Essentially, don't name the shooter. It would also be beneficial not to linger on one negative event for a week or more, but that's not as easy to limit. Ideally we would want journalists and networks to practice responsibility and leave out the name voluntarily, but it seems the drive for profit makes it necessary to step in with a legal solution. https://www.dontnamethem.org/ https://www.dontnamethem.org/
- 15155 4y agoI agree that the media should not glamorize these bad actors. > Why don't we create a law I was asking which statue would prevent this. How would that statue read? What would be "easy to limit?"
- giantg2 4y agoI'm not sure what you expect. I'm not writing some law that won't actually be used. The idea should be easy to grasp - journalists publishing/broadcasting the picture/name of a murderer who is not at large will be fined. The fine could be set a number of ways, but should be substantial and graded based on the income of the individual and organization. I think you're taking that "easy" quote out of context.
- ksaj 4y agoEspecially on a global scale. No law in the US or other non-Japanese country regarding the press is going to have bearing on Japanese laws regarding Japan's media outlets.
- concordDance 4y agoThrowing out a possible issue with this idea: it lets political parties assassinate rival politicians without losing popularity (in the case where the link isn't strong enough for a conviction but IS strong enough to say the killing was done by that party).
- giantg2 4y agoMaybe. But if you have a lone individual assassinating someone, then you've given them a platform to spread their message. It seems this was a case of an individual. If there was any evidence that this was organized by a party, then it could be appropriate to name the party but still withold the individual's name to prevent notoriety.
- yucky 4y ago>After all, we know that this will save lives. There are lots of things that we know will save lives. Banning driving of all non-emergency vehicles. Banning vices and handing out 50 year prison sentences for any violation. Banning skydiving. Banning soda. We can make a very long list of things we can do to save lives. But there is a price to pay, and that price isn't worth it. Banning free speech and the free flow of information is not a price worth paying.
- dmix 4y agoDo we in fact know that if a few big news orgs dont mention the shooters names that it will motivate them to not do it? I doubt you could ever control such a thing even if you tried (Wikipedia will have to have so it's just one more step to google it). Plus the shooters often care about change via harming their targets (creating fear in a particular group is what makes something a hate crime or terroism) which happens regardless if their actual name is published.
- giantg2 4y agoThere's evidence in the linked study as well as in anecdotal admissions by some perpetrators (eg Columbine murders expected mass coverage and hoped that it would inspire others). Is there any evidence to refute this?
- dmix 4y agoI was talking specifically about naming the perpetrator, not that news coverage might create copycats: > the [FBI] developed the “Don’t Name Them” campaign. The campaign aims to curb media-induced imitational mass shootings and suggests minimizing naming and describing the individuals involved in mass shootings, limiting sensationalism, and refusing to broadcast shooter statements or videos. This sort of thing comes up every time there's a mass shooting, commenters attack the media for naming the person. My point is that even if the media on non-specific about the names/motives those details will come out somewhere and people will find it if they want to. Trying to control specific information is a fools game. The one actual study they reference is how imitation suicides increased with coverage (ie subway jumpers -> more suicides via subway jumpers). https://sci-hub.st/https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/13811119808258290 https://sci-hub.st/https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.10... I do believe reducing the volume of coverage could certainly have an effect. Wall-to-wall coverage makes these acts notorious and puts the ideas into peoples minds. If there is going to be reporting on it avoiding biographic details on the perp won't make much difference. Plus I really doubt the main motivation of most of these shooters is to be personally named, rather they want maximum impact for their crimes. They know the specific details will spread via other channels regardless, all it needs is the original seed in the media about the general crime.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- chmod600 4y ago"There are already restrictions on speech..." There are particular categories of speech that aren't considered to be "protected speech". And those categories can't be expanded just because some politicians and judges think it's a good idea. "that same reasoning is what allows gun control." A lot of what we consider "gun control" is under active constitutional debate. Why go to all this trouble? I agree with the general idea that we shouldn't glorify mass shooters. But all we have to do is stop clicking and start to develop a cultural idea that it's wrong to report is a way that makes killers (in)famous. Mainstream outlets will stop doing it and the fringe is not very important.
- giantg2 4y ago"And those categories can't be expanded just because some politicians and judges think it's a good idea." Why not? Isn't that how the current ones came to be? "But all we have to do is stop clicking and start to develop a cultural idea that it's wrong to report is a way that makes killers (in)famous." That would be great, but what would that look like? I don't see a mechanism for incentizing them via culture. The only thing I can see is if people start sueing the media like they have gun makers for improper marketing. "A lot of what we consider "gun control" is under active constitutional debate." Is it really a lot? It seems the majority of gun control regulations still stand under the new one prong standard.
- chmod600 4y ago"Why not? Isn't that how the current ones came to be?" There's an interesting history of rights prior to the Constitution. But now that we have a constitution, there's a defined process for amending it. Of course, there is still room for interpretation. But if you allow politicians and judges to wildly change the constitution on a whim, you might as well not have one. What you are suggesting qualifies as such a wild change to the notion of a free press, and should not be permitted without an amendment. And if such an amendment were proposed, I think it would get very little support.
- giantg2 4y ago