2 ms·
> ...approximately half of the investments were predictably bad... I thought it would be higher than that. Investing in startups seems to predictably bad right
by roenxi 4y ago
> ...approximately half of the investments were predictably bad...
I thought it would be higher than that. Investing in startups seems to predictably bad right off.
If this gentleman has solid evidence that there are predictors of success for startups that would be a much more interesting signal than noting that most startup investments are bets that went bad.
- highwaylights 4y agoIt would be more useful if there was such a thing as a check list for good bets, but it’s fairly interesting (at least to me) that the founder’s background is consistently over-valued in the results. This has always seemed fairly logical to me - at the end of the day the users are investing in a product while the investors are investing in a person. The mismatch here is bound to create loss but this presents data to support.
- cinntaile 4y agoIsn't background pretty much the deciding factor when investing in a company? If we would look at the background of the founders of all the YC companies, I suspect almost all will have a "good" background.
- tlholaday 4y agoIf background is pretty much the deciding factor, the stumble from “reliance” to “over-reliance” is foredoomed.
- highwaylights 4y agoI mean I guess? The point here at least is that the data is showing that this is a poor way to judge the outcome of the company. This stands to reason, valley investment is often a conveyor belt of: Ostensibly good school -> Ivy League STEM programme -> Tech job / investment That's a very narrow selection pool to part your money on the basis of, given that by default it will produce candidates with little experience of the real world or the realities of competing in a marketplace right before they compete in a global marketplace. There are obviously exceptions to the above (there's a great many even within YC) but it just reinforces the point that having a few people pick other people to give money to based on them being their kind of people to outcompete a globally large group of yet more people performs relatively poorly as an investment strategy.
- darkerside 4y agoI'm curious if anything was modeled being undervalued for predictive value. Human sight is overvalued in the context of identifying optical illusions, but we don't have a lot of effective alternatives for making decisions about how we move about the world.
- singron 4y agoBy predictably bad, it means that the model said it would be bad and it was bad. There are also "unpredictably bad" outcomes. E.g. if 19 out of 20 that are about to receive investment are bad, the claim is that the model could identify and eliminate ~10 bad companies at that point and let you invest in a portfolio where only 9 out of 10 companies are bad. The paper has a thorough discussion about the "selective label" problem, which is largely why the claim is in this form.