4 ms·
the root problem is that school funding and teacher's reviews are linked to the students' performance on standardised tests. another significant problem that th
by zem 15y ago
the root problem is that school funding and teacher's reviews are linked to the students' performance on standardised tests. another significant problem that this causes is that teachers who work with the kids who most needed it are harshly penalised by the way the metrics are structured (e.g. someone working with troubled kids from poor backgrounds, who manages to raise their standardised test scores from an F to a C, and, more importantly, taught them how to learn, will still be rated far worse than someone who has simply drilled a classroom full of bored upper middle class kids till they can do well on the tests (whether or not they have actually learnt anything))
this article, for example, is a good read on the subject: http://blogs.scientificamerican.com/guest-blog/2011/06/27/education-reform-in-the-wrong-direction-high-stake-consequences-for-new-york-state-teachers-and-their-students/ http://blogs.scientificamerican.com/guest-blog/2011/06/27/ed...
- electromagnetic 15y agoI don't understand funding based on performance on standardised tests. I mean it's one thing if you double-blind it, but who wants to be the parents of the kid in the control group who get zero education to see how well the teachers actually improved their students abilities. The only reprieve I have for standardises testing in the UK was that a teachers opinion of you doesn't reflect on your ability to get grades. I was a d-average student in one of my classes. I never got marked well for my essays, etc. I took the exam expecting failure and received a B, comparing with friends I found I was only a few marks short of an A. The teacher never liked me, because he never liked my brother, because my brother was a cocky asshole. If I'd have been graded by him, I would have failed.
- yummyfajitas 15y ago...someone working with troubled kids from poor backgrounds, who manages to raise their standardised test scores from an F to a C... Such a teacher will receive a very high score according to most modern Value Added Modelling assessments (such as the one the article complains about). In fact, it's the teachers of upper middle class kids who are hurt the most by VAM. If the VAM predictor says your student average should be 95/100, it's hard for your students to beat that by a significant margin.