3 ms·
Wow, thanks for taking the time to make that massive reply. This kind of Inside Baseball is facinating and really helps to take the mystery out of what goes on
by ryandrake 4y ago
Wow, thanks for taking the time to make that massive reply. This kind of Inside Baseball is facinating and really helps to take the mystery out of what goes on here. Surprised that this "tree balancing" really makes much of a difference.
EDIT: I wonder if trolls deliberately wait for and then target top main-threads, in order to maximize the blast radius of their trolling.
- sokoloff 4y agoIt’s amusing to me that this submission (from pg’s 2-year-old tweet) serves to make more work for dang on a Saturday.
- pvg 4y agoLots of people do this without necessarily being trolls because they feel their comment would be lost, especially if some giant topcomment is dominating the discussion. People also do the opposite - writing a toplevel comment to discuss (berate, more often than not) multiple other comments - 'I can't believe the nattering nabobs of negativism that have been commenting here, etc'. In both cases, writing a good, non-repetitive, non-meta toplevel comment is probably better but it's more work and potentially unsatisfying - a lot of the time, a comment like that will in fact be lost in a big discussion.
- dredmorbius 4y agoAs I've responded elsewhere in this subthread, a good top-level post can often succeed in gathering enough votes / mod attention to float up. Probably not on the busiest posts (though those are something of a conversational lost cause already), but on most typical discussions without excessive comments, yes.
- dredmorbius 4y agoSearching for "by:dang <typical moderation phrase>" is a handy way for seeing what actions are taken, in what circumstances, and why. I'll admit to tailing dang's comments periodically, or searching for specific terms when people challenge / inquire about my own takes on comments. (Most often in the case of dupe / non-dupe article submissions, occasionally others.)