3 ms·
AI is an unattainable goal, not because we'll never create it, but because "what is AI" changes over time as we figure out how to do things, and give them their
by Izkata 4y ago
AI is an unattainable goal, not because we'll never create it, but because "what is AI" changes over time as we figure out how to do things, and give them their own name. Decision trees, machine learning, deep learning - each of these was "AI" at some point, but now that we can do them the magic is gone and "AI" has become more distant than it was before.
(Heavily paraphrased from a longer post I read years and years ago, no idea where)
- DonHopkins 4y agoTo answer "What is AI?" you first have to answer "What is I?" Check out the Apple ][ at the Dolphin Research Center in 1982, and Ron Reisman’s thoughts about dolphin intelligence: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CWHCTNztnwQ&t=392s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CWHCTNztnwQ&t=392s “It’s gotten to the point that I never say anything about intelligence in general. I don’t know what it means any more. I used to. But then I started trying to test it. And if you think about it for a while, you don’t know what it is.” -Ron Reisman
- EL_Loco 4y agoThe best way I heard it phrased was "AI is whatever computers can't do yet".
- kalleboo 4y agoI think among common people what AI is is clear - a computer that is as smart and clever as a human. That has never changed, and has never been achieved. But in academia what you say applies since they first thought "well a computer that can hold a conversation must be intelligent", then they created ELIZA, then "well a computer that can win in chess must be intelligent", then we got Big Blue, "well a computer than can recognize objects in an image", etc etc
- ulber 4y agoI get the point but also fully disagree. At the point where computer cognition is good enough for humans to truly fall in love, build friendships or come to hate as an enemy, I personally think not recognizing it as AI will become a fringe belief.