4 ms·
Isn't this an inherent problem when ISPs make it too easy for users to move between IP addresses? What other options do they have to stop IP-hopping vandals?
by josephcsible 4y ago
Isn't this an inherent problem when ISPs make it too easy for users to move between IP addresses? What other options do they have to stop IP-hopping vandals?
- the_biot 4y ago
- howenterprisey 4y agoRange blocks are not only entirely rational but an essential part of the toolbox for Wikipedia administrators. There are many cases where a range block is the best option, and many ranges where the only edits ever are pure vandalism. Admins consider collateral damage in all other cases. (Also: the Wikimedia Foundation has no part in this decision; it's entirely volunteer administrators.) I will say, though, the main idea is correct: IPs suck for user identification, have sucked for a while, and are getting worse every year; eventually we'll be forced to switch.
- rhn_mk1 4y agoWhat are the cases where a range block is the best option? How is discriminating based on ISP justifiable at all, barring technical noncompliance? It's irrational because it goes against a stated principle of Wikipedia.
- howenterprisey 4y agoI don't have any cases handy off the top of my head, but lurk en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WP:AIV for a while and I'm sure some will come up. It's just discriminating against ranges that happen to correspond to IPs. There's no principle that says that's not allowed. Re principle, you can always make an account. See the top-level replies to the story from humanistbot and disruptiveink.
- przemub 4y agoIt is noncompliance. Such severe actions are undertaken only when the ISP react to multiple abuse@ notifications.
- disruptiveink 4y agoWouldn't the switch just be to make it mandatory for all edits to come from a registered account? I see this the other way around, they're attempting to allow unregistered edits for most people at the cost of extra administration when they really don't have to.
- howenterprisey 4y agoThat's completely correct.
- josephcsible 4y agoDoesn't that just push the problem down a level? If they do that, then they just need a way to keep the vandal from making a new account every time his old one gets banned. What do you want them to do about that other than banning all of T-Mobile from registering new accounts? Require something onerous like phone number verification?
- josephcsible 4y agoWhat would you suggest they do instead?