5 ms·
Notable that this is published by the Discovery Institute Press, the imprint of the Discovery Institute, the people behind "Intelligent design" and "Teach the c
by tialaramex 4y ago
Notable that this is published by the Discovery Institute Press, the imprint of the Discovery Institute, the people behind "Intelligent design" and "Teach the controversy".
There have been lots of books making roughly the same argument from intuition - that it sure feels like we're special, and so therefore we must be special even if there's nothing in particular we can point to in favour of this notion - I can't strictly recommend any of them since I don't find them at all convincing but there's no need to fund the Discovery Institute if you want to read attempts at this argument.
- belter 4y agoParaphrasing something that somebody said a long time ago...You mean their computations about thinking machines are not very interesting :-)
- rbanffy 4y agoI’d add that their computations employ mechanisms that are outside the realm of logic. Or That I know white noise generators that make a more convincing argument.
- rbanffy 4y agoI find their argument to be particularly ludicrous in the light of LaMDA and DALL-e. Unless they can point to a specific process in us that’s not computing (and we can kind of define Einsteinian physics in terms of spacetime doing computation and transporting state) I’ll remain very sceptical. And Google, Siri, and Alexa all agree I’m on the right track, BTW. And on > this is published by the Discovery Institute Press, the imprint of the Discovery Institute, the people behind "Intelligent design" and "Teach the controversy". Why is this that it’s always the same kind of people that seem likely to seek comfort by chanting “You’ll not replace us”?
- 300bps 4y agoGoogle, Siri, and Alexa all agree I’m on the right track, BTW. I would argue that they are so rudimentary and universally terrible that it argues the exact opposite. They’re able to convert speech to text fairly well but understanding and taking action on that speech their common use cases are measured in the dozens. I have an Echo in every room but I use Alexa for a shopping list, weather, to play music and set my thermostat. Anything other than that and it gets very lost.
- rbanffy 4y agoSorry. I was being sarcastic. OTOH, we can’t argue they do the job of a not particularly bright human quite well, so, at least, those humans have already been replaced. There was at least one POTUS in recent history that could be replaced by a probabilistic prose generator and nobody would notice.
- belter 4y agoThe POTUS you are thinking about, at least could never be impersonated by Deep Fakes. Anybody would notice the missing outrageous statements.
- rabbits77 4y agoYou should know that Sir Roger Penrose wrote a book over thirty years ago that asserts human like intelligence is non-algorithmic, that is, unable to be simulated on a Turing Machine. Hence, the article linked to is probably right. I, much less Penrose, have anything in common with the Discovery Institute, but it doesn’t mean they’re wrong in their conclusions. Their ahem “methods” may be a bit suspect as well. To learn more read “The Emperor’s New Mind”. It’s quite a book! A good addition to your summer reading list. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Emperor's_New_Mind https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Emperor's_New_Mind
- balfirevic 4y ago> Hence, the article linked to is probably right. Only if Penrose's argument is probably right, which you seem to have taken for granted here.
- ozim 4y agoUgh... I don't need Penrose - you still have training set for AI. Humans don't have rigid specified training set, training human to live takes at least 20 years. Each human has really exceptional path and there is no way to train two humans in exactly the same way even if they are identical twins. Tell me how you do the same result with neural net that is trained in let's say 6 months, amount of data is not there. Mostly neural nets are trained on images or on sounds - humans are trained on images/sounds/touch/smell/taste/emotions for years.
- rbanffy 4y agoOur networks are continuously trained and never (major pathologies excepted) cease to be trained. OTOH, a digital network can absorb inputs at a much faster signalling rate than biological ones. Digital networks also don’t try to replicate all aspects of biological brains and are a somewhat crude approximation of their biological counterparts.
- rbanffy 4y agoI read it, and I remain unconvinced. Quantum processes may introduce noise, or may result in actual useful computation that’s unique to organic brains, but still it is a form of computation, as much as anything that behaves according to natural laws are bound to them. I’m not sure exactly what Penrose was on to in that book, honestly.
- ozim 4y agoIt is levels of abstraction. I can write DALL-e "Pope assasinated blood bath" and it will happily comply to generate images. It will not stop and think twice that there are people who might be offended by the images. It will not stop and realize that it might not be appropriate to even generate such images. Of course there are people who would happily create such pictures. Generating pictures from a sentence based on somewhat connected images is not creative, yes it is funny and might be provocative but art is not just generating images - Picasso just painting any shit would still not be Picasso but yet another painter. Van Gogh does not matter because he could paint night sky - any schmuck can paint a night sky and do it in weird way. It is story, it is bunch of other paintings he did.
- rbanffy 4y ago> It will not stop and think twice Of course it won’t. It has no concept of how images will emotionally affect the humans who see them, or humans, or that people see them.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- strogonoff 4y ago> argument from intuition - that it sure feels like we're special, and so therefore we must be special even if there's nothing in particular we can point to in favour of this notion The reverse is no less of an argument from intuition. Yes, at first thought it’s compelling to think that consciousness arises from what we consider “material world” (see naïve realism[0]), so of course we should be able to come up with some arrangement of material world elements that creates a consciousness—but there’s nothing in particular we can point to in favor of the notion that consciousness arises from material world in the first place. Neither position is known to be correct, it’s a philosophical issue in which you can argue for either side—but without an ability to show definite proof in favor of your take, ridiculing the other is just lazy thinking. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naïve_realism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naïve_realism
- Retric 4y agoThe fact you get drunk is very strong evidence though not proof that the material world creates consciousness. Physical interactions impacting consciousness in a huge number of repeatable ways isn’t proof of anything but it's by far the simplest explanation.
- strogonoff 4y agoIndeed, it’s not a proof. Deciding to buy and ingest alcohol (then neurons firing in certain ways, etc.) doesn’t violate a possible non-physicalist take in which the perception of that happening is a map of the territory that is your consciousness.
- Retric 4y agoYou can get drunk without realizing your drinking alcohol which means it’s more complicated than simple observation and expectation. Keep trying to cover all the edge cases and you can end up with a god like collective unconscious that just happens to simulate the physical laws the way we currently expect even before humanity was aware of them. Which is undetectable dragon in your garage territory.