5 ms·
It's rail wheels which are beveled, with the radius decreasing to the outside of the wheel. Your top image has the wheels reversed. There's also a flange whic
by dredmorbius 4y ago
It's rail wheels which are beveled, with the radius decreasing to the outside of the wheel. Your top image has the wheels reversed. There's also a flange which extends below the rail depth on the inner edge of the wheel
Should be, showing from the axel to the rail:
_ __________________________ _
_ __________________________ _
| | | |
| | | |
| | | |
\ | | /
\_| |_/
| |
As the car rounds turns, the inner wheel rides down and the outer wheel rides up, increasing the relative rotational radius of the outer wheel. This compensates for the fact that rail wheelsets rotate on a single fixed axis, not independently, and without a differential.
For a non-ASCII image see: https://steemitimages.com/DQmUjS7PbhzAYpkTi5A3c2QQQa7jn1c52sfFu9RDK3hnDzX/32r34t5y67543.PNG https://steemitimages.com/DQmUjS7PbhzAYpkTi5A3c2QQQa7jn1c52s...
Longer explanation: https://www.popularmechanics.com/science/a25581/science-behind-train-tracks-wheels/ https://www.popularmechanics.com/science/a25581/science-behi...
Wikipedia also discusses geometry: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Train_wheel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Train_wheel
- geokon 4y agois there a reason why they don't have the wheels spin separately? Does it make it more complicated? Or there is a disadvantage?
- nikanj 4y agoIt makes it more complicated. The wheels need to be fixed to the axel for breaks to function, so you can’t just stick a bearing in the wheel and call it a day.
- dredmorbius 4y agoThis seems unlikely.
- geokon 4y agoI'm imagining two half length axels. I guess this creates some torque but the breaks and bearing would be identical
- wiredfool 4y agoThen you'd still need bearings in the middle of the axle somewhere.
- mulmen 4y agoDon’t rail brakes generally act on the rolling surface of the wheel? Why would it be any different with independent wheels?
- bregma 4y agoNot regenerative brakes. Only friction brakes work that way.
- dredmorbius 4y agoRegen braking would operate through the same electic motor which powers the wheels in the first place. https://connectorsupplier.com/regenerative-braking-systems-rail-applications/ https://connectorsupplier.com/regenerative-braking-systems-r...
- brudgers 4y agoMy guess is at a minimum maintaining the bearings would be more difficult. A solid axel allows placing an external bearings between the truck and the axel. Hub bearings are internal and service would require dealing with the nontrivial weight of a loose wheel. See https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_railroad_truck_parts https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_railroad_truck_parts
- avianlyric 4y agoThe fixed wheels, plus the bevel create a self-centering effect. As the wheels move off centre, the bevel makes one wheel have a larger effective diameter and the other wheel a smaller effective diameter. Because the wheels have a solid axel, that forces one wheel to start travelling slightly faster than the other, causing the pair of wheels to turn. With the bevel making the wheels larger on the inside, it means that as a pair of wheels drifts right relative to the tracks, the right hand wheel rides up, starts behaving as if it’s larger, and then starts to overtake the left wheel (which has ridden down, and behaves as if it’s smaller), creating a turning effect to the left, correcting the rightward drift. When setup correctly, and travelling at a reasonable speed, the big metal lip on train wheels should never touch the track. The self-centering effect does all the work, the lip is just a backup to deal with overly tight turns, points and extremely slow running.
- geokon 4y agoI get the principle of how it works - though it seems imperfect bc it would vary depending on the weight/load. But why favor such a mechanism to just independent wheels? Or are you saying the whole setup actually tilts the carriage into the turn - helping to prevent it from tipping?
- mulmen 4y agoIf the wheels were independent the lips on the wheels would constantly ride on the inner sides of the rails. That increases rolling resistance and wear.
- RX14 4y agoThere are some trains which use independent wheels, but they need complicated mechanical centering mechanisms to replace the self-centering effect, and these are more expensive to maintain.
- dredmorbius 4y agoAny examples / explanations of which you're aware?
- dredmorbius 4y agoIt's a matter of balancing straightaway and turning performance. For a good explainer see: https://yewtu.be/watch?v=SRsm7mv0Oh8 https://yewtu.be/watch?v=SRsm7mv0Oh8 With separted axles, you wouldn't get the climbing behaviour of the outside wheel. With a fixed axle, the idealised shape of the wheels is of a double-ended cone (see the video for an example) which can ride higher on the outside of a turn. Even with conical wheels, with independent axels there's no way to impart a turning force on the carriage. I'm not entirely sure what the end result would be, but I suspect it would be a far harsher ride, and much more track and wheel wear. Probably a much higher probability of derailments as well. Cone angle varies by type of train and speeds. The video shows both freight and high-speed rail designs and discusses characteristics of both.
- hristov 4y agoYes, it is the wheels that are beveled. However, the BART wheels are not beveled, they are flat (cylindrical) at the part where the cars usually ride. See https://www.reddit.com/r/bayarea/comments/2t7x49/the_bart_wheel_profile/ https://www.reddit.com/r/bayarea/comments/2t7x49/the_bart_wh.... This is what causes a lot of noise and wear and tear. I actually researched this and it seems that it was not as stupid of a decision as a lot of people say it is. There is a problem with beveled wheels -- it is called hunting. This is when the car oscillates from side to side. Hunting is unpleasant, also causes wear and tear and noise and creates a danger of derailing. Hunting becomes more likely if the car is lighter and if it is going high speed. The bart was designed to be lighter than most existing metro systems and to go much faster than existing metro systems in certain corridors. So they wanted to prevent hunting and thus made a portion of the wheel cylindrical. So it seems that they just made another engineering trade off. And I am sure they had justification. But I do wish that when engineers make these trade offs they take human comfort into account. I does not seem that they gave sound much of a weight when making their trade offs. I think the solution is to keep the wheels cylindrical but just decouple them. I.e., not to have the right and left wheel connected by an axle. If they are independent they can move at different speeds on the turns and will not cause grinding and noise. And the wheels that are driven may be driven by different electric motors that drive the wheels by the necessary different speeds on turns. This is called vectoring and is already being done for some electric cars.
- avianlyric 4y agoOf anyone wants to see what hunting looks like, then watch a video of the London DLR. The DLR has very tight corners, and was originally built on very tight budget. As a result it uses very steeply bevelled wheels to handle the corners. The wheels do a great job on the corners, but on the straight they suffer from significant hunting, resulting in the trains wobbling side-to-side (and slightly up-and-down), at a rather alarming frequency and amplitude. Not quite enough to make you sea sick, but it’s pretty close.
- dredmorbius 4y agoThe DLR is a low-speed network with tight turning radii. I haven't found any footage clearly showing hunting (in part because it's difficult to distinguish other lateral-movement-inducing elements such as turns and switches), but the basic operating parameters are fairly clear. I suspect the wheels have high conicity. The rolling stock is also likely lighter than a heavy-rail system. https://yewtu.be/watch?v=i1pAfKsL1bk https://yewtu.be/watch?v=i1pAfKsL1bk