6 ms·
Wait. Doesn't the DMCA allow for the prosecution of DRM-breakers and content-copiers? Shouldn't the headline read that "Big Media is Going Nuclear For the DMCA"
by danso 15y ago
Wait. Doesn't the DMCA allow for the prosecution of DRM-breakers and content-copiers? Shouldn't the headline read that "Big Media is Going Nuclear For the DMCA"? or at least, "Big Media is Going Nuclear Against the DMCA's Safe Harbors"?
Also, what does Wikileaks have to do with any of this? I'm sure the author has some good points here, but it seems like he's just throwing in the latest Net-freedom controversies for the hell of it. Wikileaks did not run into opposition primarily because of copyright/DRM violations. It's been blocked for allegedly/ostensibly breaking other kinds of laws (such as national security-related ones).
- kevingadd 15y agoBig Media doesn't want to prosecute the DRM-breakers and content-copiers. They've discovered that it isn't profitable because it's too hard to hunt down every last person who pirates a movie and win against them in court. They'd rather destroy an entire industry and eliminate thousands of jobs so that they don't have to bother with the legal system.
- sp332 15y agoNot to mention several studies have found that pirates are the industry's best customers, suing them is majorly counter-productive.
- mseebach 15y agoYeah, the "going nuclear" bit seems to be a headline in search of a story. What the content industry is doing is draconian enough, but the headline is just a total non sequitur.
- cookiecaper 15y agoTheoretically if WikiLeaks were to publish damning internal corporate documents, they'd be violating copyright. I'm not sure if there are any exceptions anywhere for whistleblowing in respect to copyright violations. It's kind of a moot point because WL's biggest drops have been governmental, which are non-copyrightable by definition. I guess it's just meant to be a hedge against future leaks.
- tankenmate 15y agoAs far as I was aware only the US government has everything in the public domain. In most commonwealth countries, Canada, UK, Australia, NZ, India, et al, the copyright is either vested in the Crown or the sovereign state itself.
- Natsu 15y agoI don't know about the article, but the industry hates it because it leaves the burden of enforcing their copyright on them and they don't want to. They want someone else to do it for them, probably the government. And yet, there's no one else who can reasonably bear the burden. After all, infringement is a matter of permission. Other people can guess about who has authorized what, but no one but the copyright holder actually knows. And more than one person has, for example, released their own work on The Pirate Bay (even a "pirate edition" of that one game!) Moreover, as the Viacom case showed, sometimes even they can't keep track of who they authorized to do what and if they can't do it themselves, nobody else should be expected to do it for them.
- derleth 15y ago> After all, infringement is a matter of permission The obvious solution is to make it impossible to give certain kinds of permission, like how it's impossible to give up your 'moral rights' under German law, for example: If the government sees someone using something without being able to show they have paid for it and are operating under restrictions, they are committing piracy. If you gave it to them without enforcing those restrictions, you induced them to commit piracy, probably a more serious crime.
- throwaway64 15y agolaws like this would lead to very dark places
- derleth 15y agoWhich is my entire point. You don't think I was advocating laws like that, do you?