6 ms·
This was obvious from the moment he brought up the fake accounts problem. The stock market (especially tech) tanked, other investors started having cold feet,
by paxys 4y ago
This was obvious from the moment he brought up the fake accounts problem.
The stock market (especially tech) tanked, other investors started having cold feet, and he realized his purchase was a mistake.
It is bizarre though that Twitter leadership/board continued to engage with him on the matter – even handing him internal data to analyze – expecting a good faith resolution. Nothing Musk has done in the last few months has been in good faith. You either lawyer up and force him to stick to the agreement, or take the loss and move on. Appeasement isn't going to work.
- inerte 4y agoThey gave the data because if they didn’t that’s a valid reason for Musk to walk out of the deal. The bots are not.
- camjohnson26 4y agoBad faith has been Musk’s MO since the beginning. He even deliberately crashed Martin Eberhard’s roadster (allegedly, Tesla claims it was an accident.) https://jalopnik.com/tesla-co-founder-eberhard-sues-elon-musk-tesla-5286654 https://jalopnik.com/tesla-co-founder-eberhard-sues-elon-mus...
- hackernewds 4y agoMost forget that Elon did not found or invent Tesla
- trixie_ 4y agoMost realize it doesn't matter who founded it. Elon is the reason it is successful.
- random314 4y agoReasonable people can disagree with this thesis.
- sumedh 4y agoWhat is the counter argument?
- loeg 4y agoI'm not arguing it one way or the other, but the obvious counter is "Tesla's success was orthogonal to, or in spite of, Musk."
- marvin 4y agoYou'd have to provide some pretty compelling reasoning to support that Tesla is successful in spite of Musk; i.e. that without him, its market cap today would be higher than 780 billion dollars. Even discounting all other data, Tesla avoided bankruptcy in 2008 only because Musk tricked a key investor into believing that he could personally finance their investment round if the other investors didn't sign. You'd have a hard time tracking down a single eligible CEO who could play that role in 2008, let alone get them in a position to actually be with Tesla at the time. And this is only a single example of a pivotal moment during Tesla's history that hinges on Musk. Without Musk then, no Tesla today.
- cormacrelf 4y agoIt’s because they want him to pay the agreed price. It is an extremely good deal for the shareholders now, so they are behaving perfectly rationally. And they can possibly force him to.
- paxys 4y agoYes but it was clear (to all outside observers, not the board apparently) that Musk never intended to pay the agreed price. He was just collecting enough material from them to justify his breach, and fake users was a smokescreen. Their response to any questions/statements about fake users should have been the equivalent of "you signed the agreement, now stick to it" not "let's work together and resolve your issues".
- cormacrelf 4y agoSo? What does twitter care whether he intended to do it? He agreed to! And they can still force him to do it. So even if he drags out the litigation, they still have a strong position to negotiate a settlement for somewhere between 1 and 40 billion. Free money for his stupidity.
- philosopher1234 4y agoThat’s not how i remember the last HN discussion on this
- elliekelly 4y agoI’m not terribly familiar with the specifics of the deal but IIRC there’s a penalty clause that’s dependent on who, ultimately, backs out of the deal. It seems like Musk is angling to get Twitter to pull out and Twitter is doing everything they can to engage with Musk’s requests in “good faith” so he can’t claim Twitter has constructively backed out— a bit of M&A malicious compliance/a game of chicken, I believe.
- soneca 4y agoThey said “let’s work together “ precisely to be able to sue and increase their chances of win for acting in good faith.
- jiggyjace 4y agoHave you read the termination letter? The letter was sent by Elon's lawyers working with Twitter's lawyers according to the merger terms they had all agreed to. Why shouldn't they have expected a "good faith resolution"? A termination can still be made in M&A under good faith.
- paxys 4y agoWhere did you get the "working with Twitter's lawyers" part? This letter is sent to Twitter's lawyers informing them that Musk is terminating the agreement.
- betwixthewires 4y agoThey helped craft the agreement, according to Musk, twitter is violating the agreement which is grounds for termination as per the agreement. I'm not going to pretend to know who's right or how this will play out legally, but Twitter's lawyers did participate in the creation of the agreement and therefore the current state of affairs.
- ImPostingOnHN 4y agoI think you're getting downvoted because it's apparent that musk's naked assertions are untrustworthy, given his track record of being untrustworthy and making untrustworthy statements, so it isn't even worth considering the possibility the claims are true unless he actually brings some evidence to the table
- betwixthewires 4y agoI don't care about votes. This isn't reddit. I just have discussions on this site and that's all I care about. But on the topic, I think I'm getting down voted as an emotional reaction. I clearly said I don't want to pretend to know if he's legally right or not, a position which if most of us are being honest we should all be taking. But people aren't taking that position and they're reacting emotionally to words they don't want to hear. All I've said in the above comment was that Twitters lawyers did indeed contribute to the current state of affairs when they participated in the creation of the agreement in question. This is true by definition.
- Wowfunhappy 4y agoPresumably, if Twitter goes out of their way to demonstrate good faith towards Musk, it will benefit any potential legal cases in the future.
- PKop 4y agoThey wanted to cash out of a declining position as much as he wanted to renege on the deal... he was overpaying at that point, why wouldn't they want to sell?
- Inu 4y ago>Nothing Musk has done in the last few months has been in good faith. Isn't this itself arguing in bad faith? It's fundamentally speculative to make claims about his intentions.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bindle8932 4y agoMusk has lied repeatedly in public, so it's difficult to assume good faith from him.
- loeg 4y agoNo; Musk has demonstrated with his actions that he is a liar and his word means little. You could look at his “taking Tesla private at $420; funding secured” tweet, or his late SEC filing for his large ownership stake in Twitter where he claimed to be a passive investor days before making this offer, or any number of prior examples. If you assume good faith from Musk at this point, you are a fool.
- giaour 4y agoThat's not what "bad faith" means. If GP didn't care if their statement were true but just said it to make Musk look bad, then it would be in bad faith. Musk has been very publicly coy about his intentions for several months, so it's hard not to have an opinion at this point. Just because that opinion may be wrong doesn't mean it's offered in bad faith.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hackernewds 4y agoThe internal data grant could be so Elon has no defense when Twitter is ultimately gonna sue him next. It's coming