3 ms·
I'm ready for the fireworks. Odds are he will be forced to go through with it, but he will negotiate a lower price. Edit: This is over the mDAU thing still?
by pclmulqdq 4y ago
I'm ready for the fireworks. Odds are he will be forced to go through with it, but he will negotiate a lower price.
Edit: This is over the mDAU thing still? It's been explained to him very slowly that all the bots that post tweets all day are often not seeing ads, right? That the "monetizable" is a key part of that phrase?
- zimpenfish 4y ago> but he will negotiate a lower price How? As best I understand things, he has zero wiggle room - he either buys Twitter for the agreed price or he stumps up the $1B termination fee. And if Twitter's board did go mad and decide to negotiate a lower price, their shareholders would almost certainly block it and/or sue the board, no?
- streetcat1 4y agoI do not think that he can pay the termination fee. I.e. the termination fee itself has rules. Otherwise, he would have payed it (the fee is equal to the daily move of his TESLA shares).
- cbtacy 4y agoPretty much. I think it's more likely he's trying to set things up to make the claim that Twitter wasn't co-operative and forthcoming with the information and then try to reduce the break fee in court.
- epberry 4y agoAgree. And likewise it seems Twitter is going to court to collect the breakup fee rather than complete the deal.
- jacquesm 4y agoThey'd be nuts to do so.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoTwitter’s Chairman disagrees: https://twitter.com/btaylor/status/1545526087089696768 https://twitter.com/btaylor/status/1545526087089696768
- adgjlsfhk1 4y agoA 1B termination fee is relatively small given that Twitter's market cap is down 10B since the beginning of April.
- Johnny555 4y agohe stumps up the $1B termination fee I don't think that's even an option -- that $1B breakup fee was just if the deal was not allowed to go through due to reasons outside of his control (like if it was blocked due to regulatory reasons). Otherwise, I think he's legally obligated to go through with it -- and Twitter's board has fiduciary responsibility to hold him to it.
- ozim 4y agoNo because he bid above twitter current stock valuation so he can still go down and people might not be happy but they will not be able to sue anyone.
- ImPostingOnHN 4y agoif he goes down, that represents a material loss to shareholders compared to the price he is contractually obligated to pay so, all the same, I think the shareholders will just take his original offer and elon can reflect on his impulsivity (a joke; he won't)
- tick_tock_tick 4y agoHe has tons of wiggle room. Mostly in this will takes years to resolve, Twitter will be forced to disclose nearly every internal document that will 100% have some email or chat of employees stating, if only as hyperbole, that the bot rate they report to the public is bullshit.
- tptacek 4y agoThat will get him nowhere in the trial, because incorrect information is only a valid reason to break off the deal if it uncovers a material adverse effect, and it is virtually impossible to get Delaware courts to find an MAE. Matt Levine's shorthand for Delaware MAE is "40% decrease in profitability". Not stock price; a 40% decrease in the fundamentals. It's not happening.
- KerrAvon 4y agoStipulate for the sake of argument that courts will accept the bot argument -- don't you think discovery would be problematic for Elon? https://www.latimes.com/business/story/2022-04-12/musk-is-off-the-twitter-board-of-directors-the-tesla-twitter-bot-army-marches-on https://www.latimes.com/business/story/2022-04-12/musk-is-of...
- minimaxir 4y agoHis team apparently had a tough time verifying the data due to API rate limits. > While Twitter has provided some information, that information has come with strings attached, use limitations or other artificial formatting features, which has rendered some of the information minimally useful to Mr. Musk and his advisors. For example, when Twitter finally provided access to the eight developer “APIs” first explicitly requested by Mr. Musk in the May 25 Letter, those APIs contained a rate limit lower than what Twitter provides to its largest enterprise customers. Twitter only offered to provide Mr. Musk with the same level of access as some of its customers after we explained that throttling the rate limit prevented Mr. Musk and his advisors from performing the analysis that he wished to conduct in any reasonable period of time. > Additionally, those APIs contained an artificial “cap” on the number of queries that Mr. Musk and his team can run regardless of the rate limit—an issue that initially prevented Mr. Musk and his advisors from completing an analysis of the data in any reasonable period of time. Mr. Musk raised this issue as soon as he became aware of it, in the first paragraph of the June 29 Letter: “we have just been informed by our data experts that Twitter has placed an artificial cap on the number of searches our experts can perform with this data, which is now preventing Mr. Musk and his team from doing their analysis.” That cap was not removed until July 6, after Mr. Musk demanded its removal for a second time.
- outside1234 4y agoThey had firehose access - there was no limiting
- ben_jones 4y agoA lot of these rate limits would have been designed off the rubble of the Cambridge Analytica scandals, and would've been designed to prevent a lot of analysis. I still find it dubious that they couldn't long poll sufficient samples. I'd love to see the raw feedback of Musk's "Data Experts" versus whatever awful telephone game it became through several layers of Executives and Lawyers. I wonder if Musk just has a nepotistic data team next to him.
- fooey 4y agothe contract says they can't make any demands that have materially adverse effect on the company if he was hitting up against rate limits, it's easy for Twitter to call his requests adverse
- paxys 4y agoIf this goes to the courts then the only two options are he gets to back out entirely or he pays the originally agreed price. There's a chance of a settlement where Twitter agrees to sell for significantly less than that, but (1) there's zero incentive for them to do so and (2) they will definitely not get shareholder approval for that. One thing for sure though is that a lot of lawyers are about to make a lot of money.
- mikkergp 4y ago> a lot of lawyers are about to make a lot of money. The one thing written in this thread that I am 100% confident is true.