3 ms·
Original title: "Asleep at the wheel": Canada police’s spyware admission raises alarm - Experts warn that RCMP document detailing covert surveillance of Canadi
by mdp2021 4y ago
Original title:
"Asleep at the wheel": Canada police’s spyware admission raises alarm - Experts warn that RCMP document detailing covert surveillance of Canadians’ mobile devices highlights lax government oversight
> An admission from Canada’s national police force that it routinely uses powerful spyware to surveil citizens has prompted concern from experts, who warn the country is "asleep at the wheel" when it comes to regulating and reining in use of the technology
> Last year, a collaborative investigation between the Guardian and other major international outlets, called the Pegasus Project, revealed that spyware licensed by the Israeli firm NSO Group had been used to hack smartphones belonging to journalists, lawyers and human rights activists. // In 2021 the commerce department in the United States announced it had placed mercenary spyware companies like NSO on the country’s Entity List, effectively blacklisting them for their "malicious cyber activities" amid growing concern from US officials that the software posed a grave risk to national security. // In contrast, Canadian authorities have shown little appetite to take similar action, said Deibert [one the world’s leading experts on the surveillance techniques used by authoritarian regimes], who has briefed senior Canadian officials within successive governments
> In the parliamentary document, the RCMP [Royal Canadian Mounted Police] says it didn’t consult the federal privacy commissioner before using the technology - but said it nonetheless needs the approval of a judge when monitoring Canadians
There are two situations that may overlap here: that Statal agencies monitor all communications in the territory, and that in some cases monitoring of a specific individual is conducted through a more usual process.
In fact, the sentence later attributed to Brenda McPhail, director of the privacy technology and surveillance program for the Canadian Civil Liberties Association, about «not [having] broad powers "shrouded by secrecy" and without public accountability», seems paradoxical when applied to approved operations in specific investigations from the Police - an "elephant in the room" is left out.
Edit:
There is in fact a very strong flaw in the conclusive reasoning
> [According to Deibert] Private companies and banks presumably know a lot about your preferences, but only the government can take away your freedom and put you in jail. Only the government can end your life in some jurisdictions... That’s why there should be a higher threshold for public accountability and transparency when these tools are used by state agencies
The statement points to «"tools"» «used by state agencies», but in a public-private partnership those «companies and banks» who «presumably know a lot» (and by principle _should not_) will share information upon request. So, the tools are just a piece of it - private information should be protected in general.