3 ms·
> you can easily lose security by rolling out controls that aren't relevant to your environment but require you to add attack surface and operational overhead t
by lmm 4y ago
> you can easily lose security by rolling out controls that aren't relevant to your environment but require you to add attack surface and operational overhead to mitigate vulnerabilities that you don't have because you don't share printers or run Windows Server 2008.
Can you talk about that more concretely? I'm sure there are many cases where compliance requires you to consider a risk that's not relevant, but it's hard to imagine that thinking about each risk and taking appropriate action (which, sure, in many cases will just be documenting why it doesn't apply) would damage one's security.
At the end of the day any list of potential risks is going to be imperfect, and some will be more imperfect than others, but I'd still think that the vast majority of the time you'll get a better outcome by engaging seriously with a given list of risk factors than by treating it as an exercise in doing the minimum. If you were trying to do security from the ground up without any regard to compliance you'd ultimately end up doing something quite similar - coming up with a big set of risks and then figuring out what you're doing about each of them - and sure, you could probably start with a better-targetted one than what SOC2 has, but that sounds like a matter of degree rather than being so different that you can't get any shared use out of doing those things together.
- technion 4y agoI'm sure they'll add their own responses, but I've seen some tremendous issues caused by legacies like this. I spent a solid week including a case opened with Microsoft attempting to determine why Outlooks "report as phishing" button didn't work. That's definitely harming security, people stopped reporting phishing. The root cause was a Windows XP era Internet Explorer hardening policy that served no purpose on a modern desktop. In 2019, Microsoft removed a recommendation for an old font related security setting[0]. From a management level, a wide variety of modern best practices are already the default from Windows 2019 or so. The cognitive effort of looking at 50 security settings and convincing yourself they are all reasonable and won't break things is substantively better than the 400 or so we used to have. It's one thing to inherit this sort of legacy but it's a much worse thing to be implementing all these policies in a greenfield 2022 environment because they are all on some checklist. [0] https://techcommunity.microsoft.com/t5/microsoft-security-baselines/dropping-the-quot-untrusted-font-blocking-quot-setting/ba-p/701068 https://techcommunity.microsoft.com/t5/microsoft-security-ba...