3 ms·
Serial testing only solves the problem if the tests are independent. With complicated medical tests, they often are not independent - for example, you can have
by pclmulqdq 4y ago
Serial testing only solves the problem if the tests are independent. With complicated medical tests, they often are not independent - for example, you can have a genetic factor that makes you reliably test positive for certain cancers. Note that COVID tests were generally independent (although not completely).
If you want to flood hospitals with false positives that sounds like a good hypothesis. Then the people who actually do have cancer will not be taken seriously.
Here's an example: Suppose you test for a cancer that is very common, and 1 in 10000 people have it. Also, suppose you have a very accurate test with a 5% false positive rate and a 5% false negative rate, and those false positives are sticky. If you 10000 people the test every week, 501 of them will reliably report positive. Every one of them will then report to the hospital with the cancer. Now the hospital has to deal with finding the one true positive before injecting people with literal poison to get rid of that cancer (chemotherapy).
Since the hypothesis is "some people get cancer," you will find all of them! And you will find a shit load more of them who do not.
Compare that to today, when your doctor says "you have a small lump in your body, let's test you for cancer" - that 5% false positive rate will mean very few false positives, so a positive cancer test means that you are ready for invasive treatment.
Data is not information. You need information to make decisions. "Serial testing" only gets you data. That's why we only do it with "informational" tests like the Chem 20 and the CBC.