4 ms·
Doesn’t make a lot of sense. Generic insulin’s are already being made. Why not just buy those?
by refurb 4y ago
Doesn’t make a lot of sense. Generic insulin’s are already being made. Why not just buy those?
- witheld 4y agoPresumably they're going to make good insulin people can actually use, rather than pig insulin that practically doesn't work.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI don't give the CA government the benefit of the doubt. I'm guessing it will be generic and the high speed rail will be used to deliver it.
- refurb 4y agoNo they aren’t. They’re making a generic of an existing insulin. The same stuff other companies make.
- oneoff786 4y agohttps://www.healthline.com/diabetesmine/why-is-there-no-generic-insulin https://www.healthline.com/diabetesmine/why-is-there-no-gene... It’s complicated
- sbierwagen 4y agoThat doesn't seem to answer the question? It lists a bunch of biosimilar insulin analogues but doesn't say why California wouldn't buy them instead of manufacturing their own molecule.
- dragonwriter 4y agoCalifornia is not going to manufacture their own molecule, they are going to contract with someone, seems likely to be CivicaRx.
- refurb 4y agoSure, but why? Why manufacturer another biosimilar, with all the costs and regulatory requirements for manufacturing a new drug (the FDA regards biosimilars as "new drugs")? They could just have someone who is currently manufacturing the drug sell them at a discount (CA has immense buying power)? If it's not cheap enough, then further subsidize the cost. Same outcome, less capital needed.
- hiddencost 4y agoBecause capitalism is extremely inefficient? Insulin in the US is 5x the cost in Canada [0]. [0] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35135692/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35135692/
- kcplate 4y agoYeah, everything in Canada is cheaper than the US…oh wait
- richbell 4y ago> Yeah, everything in Canada is cheaper than the US…oh wait I don't understand the point you're trying to make.
- kcplate 4y ago
- barry-cotter 4y agohiddencost said something very stupid and kcplate mocked him for saying something that stupid. The specific stupid thing hiddencost said was that capitalism was inefficient.
- kcplate 4y agoMocked is probably a bit strong,. I was definitely pointing out the irony a bit sarcastically that virtually everything (excepting healthcare) in Canada is more expensive than the US. Right now, at least 31% more expensive.
- sbierwagen 4y agoYour target here is "capitalism"? Did Canada switch over to a Stalinist command economy when I wasn't looking?
- 4y ago
- fennecfoxen 4y agoI suspect they're not actually as good as the newer insulins. "I am an endocrinologist working in the biopharmaceutical industry, and it surprises me that we still need to scapegoat drugs like insulin for high drug prices (“Injecting Some Insulin Reality,” Review & Outlook, April 6). Absent from the discussion is the dramatic improvements in marketed insulins over the past 25 years. When we talk about modern insulin therapy, we aren’t talking about the old insulins. These agents required patients to carefully plan what they ate well before they did—they should rightly be cheap. Modern insulins allow patients better control of blood sugar and more flexibility. It takes large investments to develop medications. How much is it worth to not have to determine what you will put in your mouth 30 minutes prior to doing so? It is good those days are over." — Coleman Gross, M.D. Letter to the Wall Street Journal, published there 14 April 2022.
- Spooky23 4y agoBecause pharmaceutical research is hitting a wall in many areas, and companies are “catching and killing” generic manufacturers specifically to extract more revenue from long invented products. Government should absolutely play in this space. Hell, one of the primary anti-fungal creams (NYStatin) was developed by a female researcher and state employee in the 1960s.
- refurb 4y agoBut it’s not a new insulin, it’s just some manufacturer. Plenty of generic insulin’s exist already. Why build a new plant just to make something that’s already sold?
- arrosenberg 4y agoGovernment has no profit motive and the existing sellers are not competing on price efficiently. The CA Government can sell at cost plus and force the other players to lower their price.
- refurb 4y agoGeneric company margins are small. Easier to negotiate a big volume, then sell below cost. No need to build a new plant.
- compiler-guy 4y agoBecause California wants to drive the price down. With this system there will both be more supply in the California market and as an investor and part owner, the state can influence the price much more directly. Whether or not it works remains to be seen. But driving down the price, both for the end consumers and California state insurance providers is the goal.
- Spooky23 4y agoYou can lock in the costs. Drug prices are increasing faster than inflation. We’ll have a republican congress in the the new year that won’t be lowering drug prices via policy. California has enough diabetics on Medicaid, etc that they can make a capital investment and lock in a less steep cost curve. They don’t need to pay taxes, can borrow at lower rates, and don’t need to make money. Big players always do stuff like this when constraints exist. Walmart, Apple, Amazon are buying up ocean and air freight assets to skip the lines, for example.
- dragonwriter 4y agoBecause the generics are still expensive. Which is why Blue Shield of California, as a major health care payer (which the State of California also is), has invested in doing the same thing (with the same nonprofit that has been discussed as the most likely contractor for the California state effort.)