3 ms·
>yet not even mention that the word 'privacy' does not appear in the constitution As if the constitution is some God-given artifact, that should dictate all le
by coldtea 4y ago
>yet not even mention that the word 'privacy' does not appear in the constitution
As if the constitution is some God-given artifact, that should dictate all legal matters in perpetuity, and anything not thought by some long dead guys in 18th century is not relevant to a modern society?
- ShivShankaran 4y agoIt's funny how Americans (and plenty of other groups) cling on to a thousand year old book written by some goat herders as absolute truth. Things change and even in span of few years what's true becomes a lie
- mrguyorama 4y agoA document that those self same guys said must be changed as the times changed. They felt so strongly about this fact that they went out of their way to write at least ten amendments before the document was even finished.
- vanattab 4y agoIt has nothing to due with God or dead guys who lived in the 18th century. And yes it should govern all relevant legal matters in perpetuity unless replaced or amended through the constitutional process. I am sick of certain progressives who think it's OK to undermie constitution and other institutions because it's "hard" to do things through the democratically decided avenues. The constitution is a living document that should change over time but it should change as a result of constitutional convention process not through "creative" interpretations. There absolutely should be constitutional amenent(s) protecting abortion, digital privacy, etc.. so let's put them in there!
- fuieyemen 4y ago
- krapp 4y ago>The constitution is a living document that should change over time but it should change as a result of constitutional convention process not through "creative" interpretations. But you know what else isn't explicitly supported in the Constitution and only exists through "creative" interpretation, rather than a Constitutional Amendment? The Supreme Court's power of judicial review. They literally just made it up in Marbury v. Madison.
- Gunax 4y agoIt's not God given, but it is the law. The problem with having unwritten rules is that we don't know what they are. Do we have a right to free association? A right to body integrity? A right to death? I would be very careful about conjuring up rights.
- coldtea 4y ago>Do we have a right to free association? A right to body integrity? A right to death? That should be considered by what the population wants every period (as in a democracy). Not based on what some 300-year old guys wanted, and apocryphal court decisions, trying to decipher whether the 300-old guys idea about guns and milletias is compatible with modern-day RPGs and automatic riffles shouting up schoos, or whether privacy (which was then a default, due to the lack of dozens of later developed ways to disrupt it, and more importantly the inability to do so in a mass state surveillance scale) is a right.