6 ms·
I strongly disagree with this entire premise. I want cameras to capture the real world as faithfully as possible. The rest of us shouldn't all have to deal with
by josephcsible 4y ago
I strongly disagree with this entire premise. I want cameras to capture the real world as faithfully as possible. The rest of us shouldn't all have to deal with unnecessary artifacts (which can't actually be perfectly removed in post) just because some people like their aesthetic. This reminds me of people who think we should abandon FLAC in favor of vinyl.
- tuatoru 4y ago> I want cameras to capture the real world as faithfully as possible. Zoom with your feet, then. (That is, go there and look.) With digital, what you get is determined by the compromises made by the sensor designers, or (increasingly!) by software; with analogue, what you get is constrained by your choice of film.
- bigDinosaur 4y agoThere's nothing more boring than perfectly clean, crisp, and uniformly perfect images, but you do have a point. The issue seems to be the industry converging and removing choice though?
- solardev 4y agoI also think it's silly that imperfections should be artificially maintained just to keep a "vintage" look, but when you think about it, nothing really about modern cameras actually reflect the real world. It's all a judgment call by the sensor/algorithm/photographer/editor who together decide how the published photo looks. - CCD layering & subpixel arrangements - aperture openings & shapes - vignetting & chromatic aberrations - focal distance, white balance, ISO... - shutter speed, aperture, depth of field, focus, composition... - post-production... The comparison to FLAC (a storage medium) is a bit flawed, vs say the actual creative instruments (guitars, pianos). The article is more like the photography equivalent of lamenting the loss of Stradivarius's secret sauce. Long before a photo even gets to RAW, a bunch of artistic decisions are made by the photographer and the engineers who put together the camera and lens (and their firmware). You can't turn off all the processing, and even if you could, the camera lens doesn't really work the same way the human eye does. A "lifelike" photo would have a huge field of view but be blurry anywhere except the center focal point, have a huge dynamic range but limited depth of field, etc. And then after you go from RAW to whatever renderer makes it a JPEG, a bunch more decisions and corrections are made, with or without your input as a photographer/editor. Even if you shoot with film, there is no "calibration to reality" per se, it's all an artistic choice in terms of body, lens, film, development techniques, etc. Cameras are not "reality capture devices", they are advanced signals processors that turn a gazillion rays of light into images that match a certain preprogrammed look (or one of several, like "natural", "vivid", "sepia", etc. -- all of those being just different parameters that tweak the algorithms).
- josephcsible 4y agoI know we can't actually get perfection. I'm just saying that we should strive for it anyway, rather than intentionally adding/keeping imperfections.
- Arainach 4y agoThe point is that perfection is impossible because perception is relative. Take for example the cliche Tower of Pisa pose: https://www.google.com/search?q=tower+of+pisa+pose https://www.google.com/search?q=tower+of+pisa+pose A lens which has no distortion and no aberration still produces very different effects depending on how you compose a shot. This is reality: https://twistedsifter.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/pictures-of-tourists-leaning-on-the-tower-of-pisa-1.jpg https://twistedsifter.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/picture... So is this: https://www.boredpanda.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/funny-tourist-photos-leaning-tower-of-pisa-fb2-png__700.jpg https://www.boredpanda.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/f... And this: https://www.boredpanda.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/funny-tourist-photos-leaning-tower-of-pisa-14-5971f5eb181cf__605.jpg https://www.boredpanda.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/f...
- cardiffspaceman 4y ago> A "lifelike" photo would have a huge field of view but be blurry anywhere except the center focal point, have a huge dynamic range but limited depth of field, etc. The trope of the two overlapping discs that tells you that someone is using binoculars could be replaced with this when the director wants to emphasize some subjective aspect. Edited for clarity.
- pixelfarmer 4y agoPhotography is a wide field, and aesthetics is in the eye of the beholder, as usual. For example, if you do photography which goes towards technical fields, architecture, forensics, archaeology, reproduction, documentation in general of whatever, and also a good deal of landscape photography, chances are a more perfect rendering on behalf of the used lenses is one of the goals. Some of that doesn't even have to do with aesthetics to begin with, but it is almost a hard requirement. Let me give a counterexample: Leica Summilux 35/1.4 (FLE), or Voigtländer Nokton 35/1.7, both with a very similar rendering, which includes a very strong field curvature wide open. Namely, the focus "plane" bends to further away spots towards the image corners. Using these lenses in the right way can create a 3D effect, and weirdly enough, you can see that even in a viewfinder with a single eye, which conceptually makes no sense, but truly is like that. Seen it using A7/A7s, tested it with other persons, they all report this effect. This rendering is so unique that even non-photographer friends eventually could tell images apart made by the Leica (if around wide open settings). In return, it doesn't have the nicest bokeh, or more like you should keep an eye on the background, but I also picked it for its harsher/"grittier" rendering with that. Another example: Leica Summarit 90/2.4 vs. Zeiss Loxia 85/2.4. On my travels I use the Leica, but otherwise I try to grab the Zeiss. Thing is, the Leica, like its other 90mm brethren, suffers from veiling flare (yes, even the hailed Summicron, and also the old Tele-Elmarit), a problem the Zeiss doesn't have. In return, the Zeiss is bulkier and has almost twice the weight, so for travels (multi-day hiking etc.) the Leica has advantages over the Zeiss, despite being the inferior lens from a rendering point of view. Read: Sometimes you have to compromise on "image quality" (very fuzzy term really) for other factors like usability and so on. A common theme with the more perfect lenses: Larger + heavier, and that is not always a good compromise to take. Which means there are many factors which play into lens choice, as usual, driven by a wide range of preferences and requirements. That also means it is not really possible to make general statements for one or the other, but "depends".
- isatty 4y agoDo you have any sample images that showcase the qualities you are talking about? I can probably search it up myself, but if there’s anything you would like to showcase. Thanks!
- zrav 4y agoIndeed. A similar thing happened in the HiFi loudspeaker industry: If manufacturers simply pursued higher fidelity they'd converge on flat (on/off-axis) frequency response, near perfect impulse response etc. making them sound more similar. This is a big problem for branding so instead you'll find intentional imperfections in speakers above a certain price point to produce a certain signature sound.
- orbital-decay 4y agoAssuming we're not talking about technical photography - cameras don't capture the real world, neither do they capture impressions. They capture flat projections of the scene, frozen in time and displayed on the flat media with limited dynamic range and gamut. The human brain doesn't operate pictures at all. It reconstructs a set of ideas about the scene, and relationships between entities, which makes it impossible to represent the scene in a single picture - because those ideas are usually contradictory. Here's an example: perspective works completely differently in a photo. Brain "sees" a heavily nonlinear perspective with the focused objects seem closer, but at the same time all straight lines are perceived as straight. This is impossible to represent in a photo, it has either linear or curvilinear perspective but not both simultaneously. Non-photography artists such as painters or game developers often mix different perspective planes in one work to depict this, but this is also just a rough imitation of what they really see or imagine. Everything else works similarly. The dynamic range can't be represented in a camera+monitor system (or camera + printed media). The colors are impressions by definition, but are also skewed by illusions well known from the color theory. The motion requires you to use longer exposures, motion blur, and composition to convey in a static photo. Sense of depth, same story. Nothing you see can be "faithfully" represented in a photo. The best you can do is to interpret the scene yourself and use crude artistic tools (tonemapping in post, composition, capture-time camera tools such as DoF etc) to hope that it will induce more or less the same impressions when viewed. Painters use extremely low-contrast media for centuries yet are able to convey the impression of a blinding sun, exploiting the human perception artifacts. You can see the non-ideal lens as one of those capture-time tools to convey a certain impression. It might be imperfect at that, it doesn't induce the same impression in everyone, it can be imitated in post with technical precision - sure. People who make or listen to different mixes, listen to music with their own settings they like more, abandon FLAC in favor of vinyl, people who don't care about high fidelity in general outside of archiving, just embrace this point as well.
- ibz 4y agoYou can't "capture the real world as faithfully as possible" in the same way that there is no map projection that "portrays the globe as faithfully as possible". It's the impedance mismatch between the real world - which is incredibly complex and messy - and a snapshot of that encoded as a JPEG.