6 ms·
RIP? WTF? Android recycled a large portion of the Harmony code base (this is why the Sun/Oracle Java case is both vs Google and Apache, even if not explicitly).
by DiabloD3 15y ago
RIP? WTF? Android recycled a large portion of the Harmony code base (this is why the Sun/Oracle Java case is both vs Google and Apache, even if not explicitly).
The only thing Android does thats new is the Dalvik VM. The rest is Harmony's classpath and friends.
- rbanffy 15y agoHad they used OpenJDK, wouldn't they be Oracle-proof?
- patrickaljord 15y agoOpenJDK is GPL, that would force all apps on the Android market to be GPL too.
- viraptor 15y agoThat's not likely. The apps don't extend the JVM in any way - they just use it. It's like eglibc and any app on the system. That specific libc is LGPL, but that doesn't mean any application using it has to be using the same license. Edit: just realised it's not the best example because the apps are actually linking and that's allowed by LGPL. Better one would be probably mono which does use GPL.
- koenigdavidmj 15y agoMono is multi-licensed, as shown here: http://www.mono-project.com/FAQ:_Licensing http://www.mono-project.com/FAQ:_Licensing * The C# compiler is dual-licensed as MIT and GPL. * The tools are GPL. * The runtime is LGPL. * A few more interesting parts from Microsoft are Microsoft Permissive, with some dual licensed as Apache.
- DiabloD3 15y agoMono is a bad example because it is not one single license, and Microsoft has been pushing for purging all GPL/LGPL elements from the code to make it easier to push an anti-Linux patent attack. Say no to Mono.
- rbanffy 15y agoThis makes no sense. If that were remotely possible, IBM would never touch the thing, much less support it and I assume their legal already took a better look into it than we could ever hope to do.
- maxerickson 15y agoMany of the libraries are GPL with an exception for linking: http://openjdk.java.net/legal/gplv2+ce.html http://openjdk.java.net/legal/gplv2+ce.html
- DiabloD3 15y agoNope, it doesn't. GPL explicitly does not cross infect over things considered part of the system, including compilers and VMs. In addition, OpenJDK also includes the classpath exception to prevent cross infection.
- wmf 15y agoYes, but then Android would be so slow that it would also be user-proof.
- rbanffy 15y agoAndroid would still use the Dalvik VM. And, if they thought some parts are slow, they certainly have the resources to optimize them.
- riffraff 15y agoAFAIR no, the patent grant for openjdk is only valid if you respect the field of use restrictions (basically "not on mobile")
- rbanffy 15y agoGPL has an implicit patent grant (you cannot honor the license terms without it) and its field use cannot be restricted.
- bad_user 15y agoThe implicit patent grant is not holding in Europe and it is debatable if it's valid in the US for derivate works. Basically OpenJDK is effectivelly useless if you're not dancing on Oracle's music.
- rbanffy 15y agoCan you explain why it's not holding in the EU?
- bad_user 15y agoI'm not a lawyer, but from my understanding the implicit patents grant functions well only in the US as a product of US patent law, but is absent from the world's other patent systems. In some countries it is even disallowed. During the analysis of the Oracle-Sun merger, a lawyer from the European Commission said that the implicit patent grant from MySQL may be limited to the purpose of the original software and would not extend to forks: http://ec.europa.eu/competition/mergers/cases/decisions/m5529_20100121_20682_en.pdf http://ec.europa.eu/competition/mergers/cases/decisions/m552... Another problem with the implicit patent grant in GPL v.2 is that it was never tested in court. This is not enough reason to doubt it, but considering how the SCO lawsuit took 10 years to get solved and how many resources were invested by Novell and IBM to get to that point for basically a clear-cut decision (not only infringement was absent, but SCO didn't even own the copyrights they claimed infringed), would you really tell Oracle to fuck off in case of a threat? Also consider how patent lawsuits have gone international. Witness how Samsung and Apple are attacking each other in non-US countries. A license that's only reliable in the US is not enough anymore. And you don't even know if GPL v.2 is reliable in the US. Not until it is tested, not until there's a precedent. And yet another problem: Oracle owns everything Java, so they aren't really bound by the GPL.