66 ms·
>spirituality are non-existent. It is. It doesn't exist.
by anthk 4y ago
>spirituality are non-existent.
It is. It doesn't exist.
- mistermann 4y agoAnd yet here we are talking about it, again.
- anthk 4y agoSo do we with unicorns.
- mistermann 4y agoAn extremely common association that forms in the mind when a mind is exposed to the idea of religion. But regardless: do any conclusions derive from your observation? My point was: it is an interesting phenomenon whereby people who claim that certain things do not exist seem to have a deep interest in discussing them. Another interesting phenomenon: there are certain ideas that cause the unforced errors in cognition to spike, and religion and spirituality is one of the more potent ones - it can cause people who are otherwise exceptional at logic to suddenly lose access to those abilities. If you ask me, science should be studying this phenomenon with greater vigour due to its (plausible) causal importance.
- NateEag 4y ago> It is. [Spirituality] doesn't exist. The majority of people on the planet claim to practice some religion / have some spiritual practice. I think that means spirituality exists, as it's practiced to at least some extent by billions of people every day. Do you mean the supernatural doesn't exist? I'd readily grant that most (maybe all?) supernatural claims cannot be falsified, but that doesn't prove they're false. I recommend a much more limited claim, perhaps reflecting your personal experience, such as "I have found no evidence that anything supernatural exists."
- burrows 4y ago> I'd readily grant that most (maybe all?) supernatural claims cannot be falsified, but that doesn't prove they're false. What is the meaning of a claim whose truth has no impact on my sense experience?
- NateEag 4y agoFor many, many people, their sense experience has included some interactions with what they perceive to be the supernatural. If yours hasn't, then obviously that isn't pertinent for you personally, but it seems wise to me to admit that others have their own experience and their own interpretation of those experiences (often not easily falsified). A good example is Philip K. Dick's experience of apparently hallucinating a pink beam of light telling him his son needed medical care. He took the kid to the hospital, and found his child had a hernia, IIRC. could that be coincidence, or his drug-addled subconscious picking up on some subtle behavioral cues from his kid? Yep. Could it have been something beyond human ken? Also possible. Can we confirm or falsify either of those possibilities? I don't see how.
- burrows 4y ago> For many, many people, their sense experience has included some interactions with what they perceive to be the supernatural. How can you perceive the supernatural? If you perceive it, then it’s sense data. So photons and sound waves. > A good example is Philip K. Dick's experience of apparently hallucinating a pink beam of light telling him his son needed medical care. He took the kid to the hospital, and found his child had a hernia, IIRC. Not having a good explanation for how you know something does not imply fairies did it.
- NateEag 4y ago> If you perceive it, then it’s sense data. So photons and sound waves. This presumes materialism, which many believers in the supernatural do not grant. Even in a materialist framing, where the brain is the source of all perception and experience, these things could originate as strictly internal phenomena, not triggered by senses. It's also conceivable a supernatural being / Simulator could tweak things directly in your brain to communicate, which stays fairly materialist but still allows for non-sense-driven communication. Are these plausible? Perhaps not. They are conceivable, though. Your perspective is perfectly valid and rational, but holding yours out as the correct answer won't help you understand perspectives other than yours. > Not having a good explanation for how you know something does not imply fairies did it. Since I didn't bring fairies up, I'm not sure what that has to do with anything. If you have no good explanation for something, that's not great grounds for saying "I'm sure the true explanation lines up with the way I see the world." And yes, that cuts both ways, and a little more humility would hurt neither side.