4 ms·
The issue not being forced only. It's how valid criticisms are just tossed out of the window and systemd is developed as is because "the lead developer and the
by bayindirh 4y ago
The issue not being forced only. It's how valid criticisms are just tossed out of the window and systemd is developed as is because "the lead developer and the team knew way better than the collection wisdom accumulated over the years".
Funny thing is they have bitten by the bugs they claimed they're immune to, so they had to apply these principles like they're first adopters of these.
I've voiced my criticisms over the years, yet I still use systemd. I don't like it, but I don't hate it either.
I want to share them, but, It'll be long, so I'll just leave links to my own comments:
1- https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27651567 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27651567 - A general criticism comment.
2- https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25616356 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25616356 - A general criticism thread.
3- https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29672248 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29672248 - About bugs in systemd.
At the end of the day, if a critical component of an OS is being replaced, people at least want their concerns addressed. Want to have some conversation. Being yelled at literally and proverbially as forcing adoption of said software is bound to create some backlash.
*Edit:* Initial text contained in this reply misunderstood the parent. Corrected, clarified, softened and re-written. Sorry about that.
- WastingMyTime89 4y ago
- bayindirh 4y agoI was working literally underground with no internet connection when these events were happening, so I was never able to observe them real time. I’m not a person who whines on the net and just does nothing. If I was aware, I would be linking issue tracker ids.
- Crysstalis 4y agoThen you may have also missed the various responses to those criticisms and things that were done to address them.
- bayindirh 4y agoIt's indeed possible, but during discussions (here and elsewhere) nobody have said something in the line of "Hey, you're telling this, but the idea behind this is documented there, go take a look". Instead I got angry answers about how systemd is much better than what came before it, and I'm telling these things because I'm used to old ways and just resisting change. The mailing lists I read also had the same echo chambers of finger pointing and blaming. Heck, I even read Lennart's blog w/o knowing the page is his, and thinking "He has a arrogant team, what kind of language is that?" Moreover, do I need to remind that one of the systemd developers has been suspended from contributing to kernel [0]? Does this signal a project which is giving due credit to criticisms directed to it? Again in the same article there a link to a mail message from Ingo Molnar [1], which openly says that systemd refuses to use existing infrastructure and does things their way, w/o listening the kernel developers' advice. As you know, kernel is not an important component of an OS, so a couple of devs can just ignore the maintainers of the platform which underpins their system, and creates the foundation for their software to exist. [0]: https://www.networkworld.com/article/2175826/linus-torvalds-suspends-key-linux-developer.html https://www.networkworld.com/article/2175826/linus-torvalds-... [1]: https://lkml.iu.edu/hypermail/linux/kernel/1404.0/01727.html https://lkml.iu.edu/hypermail/linux/kernel/1404.0/01727.html
- Crysstalis 4y ago>The mailing lists I read also had the same echo chambers of finger pointing and blaming. That sounds about the same as every open source mailing list I have ever seen, like every single day on lkml. If you have a question about documentation, you can ask it again to someone else, if you didn't get a response the first time. If you are talking about the systemd mailing list, I have seen Lennart respond informatively to plenty of user questions. >Moreover, do I need to remind No, please do not. You don't need to, I am not interested to re-read the same 8 year old flamewars that were spammed on lwn and slashdot. Please do not beat this dead horse anymore. If you really think that this finger pointing and blaming is a problem, then I ask you please do your part and don't keep digging up these old petty arguments which is also just more pointing the finger and blaming. If you do have a concern that is still active now we can discuss that.
- Clubber 4y ago>Tell me you have never opened the issue tracker without telling it to me. This cliché needs to die.
- happymellon 4y agoThis is probably the same issue with Wayland. There are some massive quality of life improvements, but then there a few rough edges and papercuts and rather than address them, the conversation gets shut down.