4 ms·
> "Here is the cash price. We won't know your HDHP insurance price until after we bill them, which could be good for you or could be bad." This is the reason t
by lelanthran 4y ago
> "Here is the cash price. We won't know your HDHP insurance price until after we bill them, which could be good for you or could be bad."
This is the reason that non-emergency healthcare is so expensive - the purchaser does not know the price of something at the point of purchase.
This results in the price being significantly higher than what the market can bear.
When consumers are informed and can force suppliers to compete with each other, prices go down to exactly what the market can bear.
Emergency healthcare is a different beast, but will probably also decrease if non-emergency healthcare prices was left up to the market to set.
- nosianu 4y ago> the purchaser does not know the price of something at the point of purchase. This is only solvable for the cases where what needs to be done is completely known and certain in advance. Which for very complex human biological systems would not be the majority of cases, unless providers decide to only deal with health issues that fit that criteria and send everybody else to someone else. I think the problem of not being able to accurately predict the required care is an intrinsic part of health care. Some of it actually is taken care of in some way, for example, if you go to ER they will only fix any immediate urgent issues and then send you home. Or, they send you home after n days in the hospital no matter what (example links: https://www.ombudsman.org.uk/sites/default/files/page/A%20report%20of%20investigations%20into%20unsafe%20discharge%20from%20hospital.pdf https://www.ombudsman.org.uk/sites/default/files/page/A%20re... or https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12568426/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12568426/). > When consumers are informed and can force suppliers to compete with each other, Uhm... how do you imagine this would happen? Genetical engineering so all humans become standardized clones with identical completely predictable issues? I think you severely underestimate the inherent unpredictability. Simple stuff like teeth cleaning can be a price known in advance, or coming in only to renew a prescription for a known health problem, but many, most?, of the "real" issues are not. OR, what would happen if you enforce this is that the MDs would be forced to press the cases into the pattern. They may think they should order an additional test or imaging procedure after actually looking at the patient, but since it's not in the pre-approved plan it would not get paid, so they don't, only things that were known before any doctor looked at the person get treated and only using the predicted methods.
- lelanthran 4y agoThe majority of healthcare is for routine and known in advance procedures, not for emergency or exploratory procedures. Sure, the GP might want to order tests, but the cost of the test will be known in advance, the cost of the consultation was already known by the patient. The patient can tdecide which radiologist they want, using price as a criteria if they want to. The existing method is basically "you can only know what the cost is after you owe it to us", which is, frankly, insane. It allows the sellers to set a price that the ma let cannot bear, which results in secondary markets that provide insurance and skim even more off the top.
- nosianu 4y ago> The majority of healthcare is for routine and known in advance procedures Yes what kind of procedure is needed often is known in advance. The details often only emerge after it's been started though. Just because it's routine does not at all mean it's all predictably-in-advance the same throughout, except for really basic stuff, which in turn is unlikely to be the big cost driver.
- lelanthran 4y ago> Yes what kind of procedure is needed often is known in advance. The details often only emerge after it's been started though. Just because it's routine does not at all mean it's all predictably-in-advance the same throughout, except for really basic stuff, which in turn is unlikely to be the big cost driver. I dunno that I'd call a broken leg "really basic stuff". This is what I responded to and what I quoted in my original post: > "Here is the cash price. We won't know your HDHP insurance price until after we bill them, which could be good for you or could be bad." So, yeah, the supplier currently knows in advance what it costs to fix a broken leg. There is no reason for the price of more mundane medical care to be opaque at all.
- Joeri 4y agoWhen you take your car in for repair, you also can’t know for sure what the cost will be, because cars are complex systems and every car is unique in its own way. But if the garage overcharges you then you will figure this out and you will not go there again. In the US healthcare system because of the lack of price transparency it seems to be impossible to know which hospital or doctor overcharges, and so a free market cannot arise. It is not even possible for a competitor to advertise better prices, because there is no practical way to check that their prices are indeed better.