6 ms·
The parents should sue themselves. Go after the negligent enablers charged with the safety of their kids.
by metadat 4y ago
The parents should sue themselves. Go after the negligent enablers charged with the safety of their kids.
- bergenty 4y agoParents should surveil their kids 24/7?
- lillecarl 4y agoDepends on age. Either way it's the parents job to keep their kids safe until they're $legal_age. Sometimes this might mean teaching common sense, sometimes it might mean not exposing your kids to TikTok. It feels like common sense is a dying thing, could it be because we specialize further and further? I "can't cook" for example.
- aaplok 4y ago> Either way it's the parents job to keep their kids safe until they're $legal_age. If someone sells alcohol to a minor they can be sued and will likely be in trouble if the child is harmed. It is the seller's responsibility to make sure they don't and it wouldn't enough to have a sign saying "please don't buy if you are a minor". They must actively check. Same thing with firearms. Even the (adult) entertainment industry works like that. Here too tiktok "sold" a product to some kids, and these kids were harmed. Consequently they have some responsibility over that. Why should the IT industry get away with practice that would not be accepted in any other industry? The role of parents is not to keep their kids safe at all costs. If it were then just keeping children locked up until their majority would be optimal parenting. Instead we as a society should thrive to make the world safe for those kids rather than just pretend it's the exclusive responsibility of their parents.
- popcube 4y agohow can they do? everyone give their kid cellphone or iPad now, even they try to control this in early stages, if kids are different to other kids in school, they will bad and try to change themselves. finally, if someone upload videos that design to murder kids, it just will happen.
- fjfifidorvrf 4y ago
- yunohn 4y agoHow do you propose they check? Active Facial recognition? Parents login to devices and give them to their kids, the vast majority do not setup child profiles or enable restrictions.
- viraptor 4y agoThis is school age. You have to assume that at that point someone they talk to will have access to anything on the internet or will pass any information they want. All the common sense and supervision will not save you from kids interacting, unless you plan to never let them out of the house.
- BaculumMeumEst 4y agoParents are not the ones exposing their children to Tiktok. Most kids go to public school. Hopefully further elaboration is not needed for HackerNews readership. "Teaching common sense" sounds very effective for young children with developing minds notorious for making terrible decisions. If only those parents had thought of it sooner.
- lillecarl 4y agoI don't see any argument here, kids go to public Schools and get shown TikTok. But it's not like TikTok hasn't made headlines for some time now. An engaged parent might talk to their kids about not doing the stupid things they find on TikTok. I'm not saying TikTok is right in promoting harmful things, it's like the town square lunatic on steroids, but at the end of the day kids are going to be exposed to stupid shit through all their life (as you say) so if it's not TikTok it's something else, teach your kids not to choke themselves to death intentionally.
- bergenty 4y agoCalling TikTok the town square lunatic is not an apt analogy. The town square lunatic is isolated, can’t reach a lot of people and doesn’t have peoples attention for very long. There are legions of crazies online that have banded together to really push terrible propaganda that very few adults, let alone kids would be able to resist.
- jmprspret 4y agoWatching over your kids is 'surveillance' now? Look, I get not invading the privacy of your 14 year old, but monitoring or restricting what children can see online at 8-9 sounds perfectly reasonable to me. Children shouldn't have unrestricted internet access until at least 13 years old.
- galleywest200 4y ago13 seems like an arbitrary number. Why not 16? Or 12? 18, 21?
- matt-attack 4y agoBecause it’s entirely common to use articulate cutoffs. It’s considered a felony to have sex with a 17 year old boy on his eve preceding his birthday but it’s A-ok the next morning. Same goes for getting drafted, owning guns, aborting fetuses, and driving cars. A think is wrong one night and because fine the next morning. It’s kind of like the Ship of Theseus.
- matt-attack 4y agoWow unrestricted internet access at 13? I guess I’m an overprotective parent now because I would try to avoid it long after that. Not that I use the MPAA as any sort of authority on parenting but rated R movies are typically prohibited by unaccompanied kids under 18. The internet is way worse than any rated r movie. It’s rated XXX to use the MPAA’s metric.
- jmprspret 4y agoNo I agree it should be older than 13. I mean at an absolute floor minimum.
- rvz 4y ago> The girls were 8 and 9 when they died last year after viewing the challenge, which encouraged users to choke themselves until they passed out, according to the lawsuit, which was filed on Thursday in Superior Court in Los Angeles County. How were they able to get on to the platform in the first place? So TikTok allows 8 to 9 year olds to sign up on there and they don't check / verify their ages? If YouTube is able to do KYC age checks, why can't TikTok?
- willcipriano 4y agoBill Clinton signed COPA into law in 98, it requires companies that distribute harmful online content ensure that they aren't doing so to children, but the ACLU sued so it never took effect. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Child_Online_Protection_Act https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Child_Online_Protection_Act
- salawat 4y agoAge checks have always been an honor system sort of thing, and lets be real: Lesson number 1 of internet access: don't share your personal info with anyone. They don't have the right to it, and you don't know what they'll really do with it. Regardless of a majority of people completely missing the bus on this valuable lesson, it also negates the usefulness of such measures.
- geoduck14 4y agoFun fact: I volunteered for a group that taught middle-school kids how to code. We used Chrome books and and MIT drag-and-drop coding editor - it was awesome. The first step was to sign-on the the Chrome books - which included a "check box" - are you 13 or older. So the first lesson we taught the kids was how to lie about your age on the internet. (As an aside, the kids previously had parental consent, so it was legit, but still...)
- theandrewbailey 4y agoIndeed: > Lalani Erika Walton ... got her first cellphone on her 8th birthday > Arriani Jaileen Arroyo ... received a phone when she was 7
- thomassmith65 4y ago
- Pakdef 4y agoAre the odds still good at 3 children? /s
- thatguy0900 4y agoThat's been the general child strategy long before elon
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Justin_K 4y agoParenting is not as easy as you think and can be severely difficult for disadvantaged populations. While it is easy to blame parents, you can't always blame the parents.
- cush 4y agoTikTok has been the #1 app on the app store for years and is serving instructional videos of children committing acts of self-harm. Distributing content like that warrants some liability.