4 ms·
> Sony discontinued global sales of movie and TV content in August 2021, but at the time, it was promised that content already purchased would remain accessible
by josephcsible 4y ago
> Sony discontinued global sales of movie and TV content in August 2021, but at the time, it was promised that content already purchased would remain accessible in future.
> As of August 31, 2022, due to our evolving licensing agreements with content providers, you will no longer be able to view your previously purchased Studiocanal content and it will be removed from your video library
Sounds about right for Sony.
- 2Gkashmiri 4y agowhy are we "expected" to honor their copyright for eternity when they do not honor their commitments ala "evolving licensing agreements". what if i honored your copyright as long as it "suited me", then one day it didnt.
- nikanj 4y agoBecause we have little money for lawyers, while they have much money for lawyers
- thaumasiotes 4y ago> what if i honored your copyright as long as it "suited me", then one day it didnt. That is already how consumers behave. You're living the dream right now!
- alexeldeib 4y agoLegal repurcussions differ. IMO it comes down to: what’s the likelihood someone pursues me, and will I survive the expected cost of my defense. Nobody likes love letters anyway. Individuals may have a lower risk, but the cost is high if someone decides to come after you. Large corporations can take the legal costs far more easily.
- kmeisthax 4y agoThere's ways to reduce your risk in this sort of thing. The reason why people come after individuals is because BitTorrent is an insanely risky system. The achilles heel of P2P is that it has no privacy whatsoever, so whoever wants to extort[0] individual pirates can do so. However, direct-download sites generally do not confer risk onto their users in the same way. Even if the site gets taken down or sued, copyright owners generally don't care about following their logs to find individual downloaders. While they still probably can be sued[1], there's no reason for a legitimate party to do so. At that point the copyright holder got what they wanted, and marching down to everyone in the server logs' house to make sure they delete their infringing movies is absolutely stupid. For the same reason I've never liked the idea of "P2P YouTube alternatives". People rightfully complain about how they mishandle anything related to copyright, and they do, but the alternative is having every copyright holder with a chip on their shoulder financially cripple anyone who watched a video they didn't like. [0] Legal scholars will probably object to my use of the word "extort". Yes, if you have a legal claim for relief then threatening to sue for it is not extortion, it's just the law. However, the only way to actually make antipiracy enforcement at an individual level not financially crippling is to cross the line into actual extortion. The Prenda Law and Strike 3 Holdings incidents are good examples of how easy it is to do so. [1] The law is actually somewhat ambiguous on where the infringement actually is when you download something. I used to think "uploading equals infringement", but there's been some court opinions arguing that either both uploading and downloading are infringements, or that they infringe different parts of copyright. Nobody's bothered to prosecute a direct-download pirate to the point where this matters. Of course there's also Japan which has a law that explicitly makes mere downloading infringing. There be dragons.
- alexeldeib 4y agoI generally agree with you. I’d rather not play the odds on exposing my identifiers anyway, whether p2p or direct. Might as well go the extra mile and make sure whatever IP is non associated with me, so direct download over tor or whatever — you get the idea. Why give someone the chance?
- LeoNatan25 4y agoDue to my evolving licensing disagreement, I use torrents for all my movies and TV show watching needs.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- JohnHaugeland 4y agoYou're confusing the creator with the distributor platform You don't get to steal from a musician because Sony cheated you . > why are we "expected" to honor their copyright Because you don't want to be a thief . > they do not honor their commitments They do, in fact. It seems like you just assumed they committed to something they didn't, and are angry now that you've finally read the actual commitment. . > what if i honored your copyright as long as it "suited me", then one day it didnt. Then you'd be a thief who pointed fingers at other people to justify your own choices
- 2Gkashmiri 4y ago>You don't get to steal from a musician because Sony cheated you elsevier copyrights papers on their own name. should we fuck with them ? >It seems like you just assumed they committed to something they didn't, and are angry now that you've finally read the actual commitment. sony committed to keep those movies but now they are backtracking on that commitment. why?
- Mezzie 4y ago> elsevier copyrights papers on their own name. should we fuck with them ? Unironically yes. Fuck Elsevier and what they've done to academic publishing.
- effingwewt 4y agoRight, or they could offer refunds and it wouldn't be so bad. This days after Nintendo letting us know they 'are unable (read- unwilling) to offer refunds. We need consumer protection laws that do something, because since the 1990s businesses have made anti-consumer practices their bread and butter. They don't fear us, the laws, or government in general. Businesses fucking lie cheat and steal every single day.
- throw_away23823 4y agoSeems like they should have agreed on better licensing agreements. I see the point for subscription based services, but in this case they should have an agreement to continue streaming for those who have purchased it. The content provider has been paid for it too, right? I am not a lawyer, but I don't think licensing agreements like this is not enough in a consumer court. When you purchase something, the consumer expects to be able to access it for as long as the distributor exists. The services use the term "Purchase" or "Buy". If that is not actually the case, they should call it something else. Otherwise it is misleading the consumers, no matter where they hide the small print in the license agreement. At a minimum I would expect a refund, as they are no longer providing the service that was paid for.
- ge0rg 4y agoIf complaining and asking for a refund doesn't yield a result, you will have a very hard time finding a lawyer to get this through the courts, given the rather marginal value of the content that you "purchased".
- mnw21cam 4y agoIf you have "purchased" a decent collection of these films, it'd probably be worth your time going to the small claims court.
- ImPostingOnHN 4y agoI believe some European countries employ government officials who prosecute attacks on consumers that violate consumer protection laws
- ratww 4y agoI really hate Sony. I had a Sony Bravia TV for several years, and bought it because it came with a "Netflix compatible" sticker. Netflix however wasn't really compatible from the get-go, and they promised it would work in the next upgrade. I wasn't in US/EU so simply returning it wasn't possible. They kept promising it would work in the next upgrade, and I would upgrade, even though each time it was making the TV incredibly sluggish. Eventually five or six years passed and the TV stopped receiving upgrades and it never had Netflix.
- sofixa 4y agoDoesn't your country have laws against false advertisement? Such bullshit would have gotten them a (not huge, but still, it's a Matt of principle) fine in the EU.
- JohnHaugeland 4y ago> Such bullshit would have gotten them a (not huge, but still, it's a Matt of principle) fine in the EU. This was brought to the EU and the EU didn't do anything
- ratww 4y agoThey did but since I believed their promises for too long I was the sucker stuck with a shitty TV.
- a4a4a4a4 4y agoI mean, it was probably Netflix compatible via HDMI? I don't see the problem here. \s
- ratww 4y agoYou're joking but at some point they really used this argument.
- kwith 4y agoOlder Sony Bravia TVs that just barely met the specs for streaming applications had to go through such roundabout ways to actually stream the content. They did not support the latest streaming standards (DASH/HLS) and basically had to stream raw MP4 files. They were a very exceptional case device at least at Prime Video. Newer devices obviously supported the regular streaming standards. At this point (and even 5 years ago), getting a little streaming HDMI stick will provide an infinitely better customer experience for a ~$35 investment. Most smart TVs just don't have a great user experience compared to the devices designed around that.