4 ms·
Its kind of confusing to me what the difference between this and a traditional vaccine is.
by bawolff 4y ago
Its kind of confusing to me what the difference between this and a traditional vaccine is.
- Traubenfuchs 4y agoTraditional vaccines are either weaker versions of the same virus created through "breeding" in animals or other manipulations OR they are replication deficient viruses, that means they can only replicated in specialized lab cells, but not in our real, normal cells. Nanoparticle vaccines are less traditional in the sense that they do not contain a virus at all, but just particles that have the virus signature, to trick your immune system into building protection against the real virus, that has the same signature. mrna and vector vaccines are even less traditional: They literally infect your existing, healthy cells and turn them into factories for nanoparticles. Eventually those cells are killed. The amount of particles produced for those vaccines is indeterminate, potentially leading to heavier side effects ("reactions") and the death of the infected cells itself is also not healthy.
- bawolff 4y agoBy traditional i meant protein subunit vaccines.
- didibus 4y agoTraditional vaccines are inactivated viruses, you inject killed viruses which are thus inactive but might still allow the immune system to react and build immunity, though you often need an adjuvant to trigger a strong enough response. This is a protein based vaccine, some traditional vaccines also use this method, like the Hepatitis B vaccine, where basically you inject some of the protein from the virus instead of the whole virus as with the inactivated method. You can also combine multiple proteins into a nanoparticle as is done here. The idea of combining proteins from multiple various SARS into a nanoparticle is what's novel here. mRNA vaccines on the other hand are new with COVID-19, they are kind of similar to protein vaccines in that they end up producing proteins from the virus, except instead of injecting the proteins directly, we take a segment of the genetic code of the virus and we deliver that to some of our cells so that they produce the protein for us.
- rob_c 4y agoNice summary. Also explains why sputnik the vaccine from Russia was developed so quickly and was effective. Traditional vaccines work. As for why they stifled production and roll out is another matter entirely, maybe mass production was difficult/expensive when there is a mad dash for reagents. I'm not making a statement on it being better or lasting longer and in all honesty there is little data to prove that one way or the other.
- igor47 4y ago> explains why sputnik the vaccine from Russia was developed so quickly and was effective FYI Sputnik clinical trial results were based on clearly faked data, and that vaccines effectiveness is highly uncertain.
- rob_c 4y agoand the safety, efficacy and all of the claims/statements from pfizer et. al. are trustworthy. Look it up again, in western clinical trials it performed as well as was expected 70% or so efficacy as was claimed with almost no identified serious side effects. Of course the data at the start was optimistic, but then in the west it was portrayed as 1000% safe by proponents despite the growing number of lawsuits for the 0.001% of cases where it was extremely NOT.
- didibus 4y agomRNA vaccines have the advantage of being lower cost to make and faster to develop. Traditional vaccines can work, but finding ways to kill or attune a virus in a way that still triggers an immune response that can fight off the live virus is tricky. With protein based one, finding the right proteins and finding a way to produce those proteins for injection is also tricky. I also forgot to mention Adenovirus Vaccines which are also kind of new in that there's only newer vaccines like for Ebola and malaria that are based on it. This similarly delivers genetic material from the virus to our cells so they produce the proteins, except the genetic material is delivered through another virus, instead of by using mRNA. Manufacturing the adenovirus carrier is trickier than manufacturing mRNA. The Sputnik-V vaccine is an Adenovirus vaccine, so not something I'd consider a traditional vaccine, it has much more in common with mRNA, in that it programs our own cells to produce proteins, the difference is it does so by having an Adenovirus inject DNA into our cells, instead of having mRNA wrapped in lipids be the trigger to our cells.
- l33tman 4y agoTo the sibling commenters here: "traditional vaccines" are much more than killed-off viruses. They can be made of manufactured sub-units of viral proteins for example. There has been continuous development of vaccines ever since the first ones were developed. In general, the problem is not getting (parts) of the virus into the body. This can for sure be done in many many ways. It's getting the immune system to care enough to start manufacturing and remembering the antibody formulae for future infections. One traditional way is to add an "adjuvant" to the viral subunits (or similar), which is designed to trigger the immune system. In either case, usually you do require to trigger some kind of local inflammation. When your arm hurts after a vaccine injection it's a good thing.