6 ms·
A big bet on geothermal could help prevent a climate catastrophe
- lven 4y agohis got me thinking about the earth's heat flux to the surface. It comes from primordial heat and radioisotope decay of thorium and uranium. Wild that geothermal energy is really just nuclear decay energy, just like the mars RTGs. But disappointing that it ain't all that much at just 47 TW, compared to the sun's 200,000 TW on the Earth's surface. And of those 47 TW, only 14 TW are on land. Not even close to enough to power mankind and our 20-40TW of primary energy today, and hopefully much much more in the future. Cool stuff, but we gotta think bigger.
- dredmorbius 4y agoGeothermal is decidedly limited. The deep-bore technology Homer-Dixon discusses is highly ambitious and would be tremendously expensive. There are extensive geothermal power facilities, however, and a surprising amount of the readily-accessible generating capacity is already utilised throughout the world, the primary exception being in the African Rift Valley. What Geothermal offers that wind and solar don't is high-reliability dispatchable peaking and night-time base-load power. Those loads are low but relatively predictable. There's a challenge with geo in extracting too much thermal energy too quickly, and fractional use on an as-needed basis might result in both longer-term utilisation per site (before the rock is cooled below practical usable levels) and more reliable generation capability for a given site. A future low-carbon / renewables energy regime will be based on a mix of sources. Geothermal is an excellent option for that mix.
- ncmncm 4y agoThe drilling method described is distinguished from conventional methods by being much cheaper, besides being able to penetrate much deeper; and usable anywhere with stable geology, not just in a few select hot spots, as now. So, if geothermal can get its operations cheaper, it could be good competition for wind and solar. Once plenty of storage capacity is on the grid, overproducing will not ever be a problem: the grid will absorb as much energy as any well can produce, provided the price is right. This last is why nukes have no future: they cannot produce power at a price the market will pay.
- dredmorbius 4y agoI'll confess to being unfamiliar with the specifics of the technology. I'm also generally favourably inclined toward Homer-Dixon's work. That said, the technical challenges, and costs, of drilling through many kilometers of rock are considerable. As are those of operating geothermal generation sites based on such bores. The far less challenging Habenro project in Australia is a case study of early estimates being proving exceedingly optimistic: I'd become aware of that specific project about a decade ago through ... a highly-positive puff-piece published in an overly-friendly Australian energy publication. The tone and fast-and-loose benefits descriptions set off a few alarms. The project ended up as a failure, the company running it pivoted out of geothermal energy. https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/1wpa90/how_not_to_write_about_renewable_energy_the/ https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/1wpa90/how_not... http://www.theregister.co.uk/2013/05/02/geodynamics_habanero_goes_live/ http://www.theregister.co.uk/2013/05/02/geodynamics_habanero... I suspect most of the other links in my Reddit piece are dead, though archive copies may exist. Energy Watch article archive: https://web.archive.org/web/20130805195650/http://www.energywatch.com.au/news/article/Geothermal_Energy_Plant_Outperforming_Expectations https://web.archive.org/web/20130805195650/http://www.energy... ASX link seems dead. Advertiser on SA Geothermal: https://web.archive.org/web/20130420153842/http://www.adelaidenow.com.au/business/sa-business-journal/sa-geothermal-explorer-geodynamics-commissions-habanero-pilot-plant-at-innamincka/story-e6fredel-1226611869930 https://web.archive.org/web/20130420153842/http://www.adelai... AGEA: https://web.archive.org/web/20140126042126/http://www.agea.org.au/news/2013/geothermal-energy-heating-up-in-australia/ https://web.archive.org/web/20140126042126/http://www.agea.o... All of that said: - Geothermal does have long-established, well-proven, economical capability. - I'm convinced humanity's energy future will largely be renewables. - The ultra-deep plasma-torch borhole stuff might work. It's something of a longshot though. That said, I'd like to see related technology (e.g., the boring bits) and trial projects attempted. Even the Habenero project wasn't an utter waste --- it was an experiment, just one that didn't pan out. It would have been far more worthwhile for it to have received coverage which portrayed it accurately, however.
- ncmncm 4y agoActually I don't think they will normally (maybe ever?) need to drill down tens of km, or even ten km, to get to enough heat. I would like to see steam turbines displaced by something that doesn't need so much maintenance (high-pressure CO2?), so that geothermal could become more competitive with other renewables. But developing tech like that is no walk in the park. GE will do it when their market for steam turbines starts to fall off, faced with renewables.
- ncmncm 4y agoThat 14 TW is just what leaks out naturally. But earth is an excellent insulator. Drilling down deep, all the energy extracted would be in addition to the 14 TW, and really as many TW as you could ever use. The main problem with geothermal is that it is quite a bit more expensive than solar and wind, with an "opex" renewables don't have: regular overhauls of the steam turbines. So, a bet on geothermal would be a bet that storage built after there is enough renewable generation to charge it from will not also be cheap. Not a good bet: storage is, for the most part, just E = mgh and E = Fx, requiring only mid-20th-century engineering. (That is not to say more exotic methods won't also be used. Synthetic ammonia, good for fuel and fertilizer, is also a good storage medium. And, better battery chemistries surface all the time, with megafactories for certain of them already under construction.) Just now, most storage schemes you read about have not had the professional engineering treatment, so are over-complex and expensive. When actually built out, much cheaper, simpler, and more reliable versions of those things will be used. (But Energy Vault's will not be. I predict they will pivot to something orbital soon, to string the saps along.) Drilling for geothermal might get a lot cheaper, using the tech described in the article, but you still have the steam turbines. That new gadget that turns heat radiation directly into electricity with no turbine might eliminate that expense and make geothermal competitive, but it also might turn out too expensive to use.
- vanattab 4y ago>But disappointing that it ain't all that much at just 47 TW, compared to the sun's 200,000 TW So 1 terrawatt = 47 terawatts
- wkearney99 4y agoWe had geothermal put in when we built new. Given a suburban MD lot and the large size of truck necessary to bore two 350' deep wells, it's far too messy a job to do without trashing the site due to all the water and resulting mud. It exchanges 55F year-round (closed loop with just water running through the tubing). It's been running quite reliably for 9 years now. We nearly tripled the square footage but our total energy costs stayed almost exactly the same. Went from gas heat/electric cooling to all electric geothermal. We still have natural gas for a backup generator, cooking and laundry dryer. We kept gas for kitchen/washing because there's a monthly minimum for gas service that we'd use for the generator. DC's Pepco power is notoriously unreliable.
- ncmncm 4y agoThey quoted $50,000 to $90,000 for me. That would be quite some years' bills. Near-surface geothermal seems a better investment, if you have room for it.
- wkearney99 4y agoState and federal tax credits offset it somewhat. There's also the benefit of, y'know, not burning fuels at the site. My paying somewhat more over time for the initial outlay seems a reasonable expense. A purely selfish side-effect is NO NOISE from outdoor condenser fans. Three of them necessary would have wasted a lot of space too, and been more maintenance items. Near surface only works if you've got a lot of square footage to spread it out. The average suburban lot would not have the space for it (I thought that would have been obvious).
- ncmncm 4y agoAs I said, "if you have room for it".
- benj111 4y agoYou're talking about a ground source heat pump though? Which is distinct from geothermal.
- Proven 4y ago
- ncmncm 4y agoThe article trots out the usual falsehoods about solar and wind encroaching on "vast swaths of territory", and bulk utility storage in batteries. Solar will not take over land people want for anything else. (Although, desert solar farms are a very bad idea, but thus far easy to sell to ignorant investors.) Solar coexists synergetically with existing uses, most especially reservoirs and canals, but also pasture and crop land, and industrial rooftops. Likewise, wind coexists nicely with pasture and boat traffic. Utility storage will mostly not be in batteries, but in media much, much cheaper.
- 41b696ef1113 4y ago>Although, desert solar farms are a very bad idea... As an ignorant doofus, care to explain why? Sticking solar panels in otherwise empty land seems like a good idea.
- dx034 4y agoMaybe because of the ecosystem? Although it doesn't seem to be too invasive if you can even grow crops under solar panels.
- ncmncm 4y agoThey get very, very hot, so their conversion efficiency falls sometimes as low as 12%. They also get dusty, which can cut conversion by as much as 80% again unless you dust frequently. And, getting so hot, their useful lifetime is reduced to as little as 20 years. Float them on a reservoir instead, and conversion efficiency is improved to as much as 23%, lifetime increased to... nobody knows yet. Evaporation is reduced. Biofouling underneath is reduced. Some wildlife prefers the shade, under. Turtles like to climb up on the edge. And, cleaning is easy. (Search: "floatovoltaics") Float them on a canal, likewise; the evaporation and biofouling reductions are extra important there. California estimates they could generate 12 GW on its canals, and prevent millions of gallons of evaporation loss every year. Stand bifacial (double-sided) panels in fencerows on cropland, running north-south, far enough apart to drive a tractor and stuff between. They pick up morning and evening sun, while protecting crops from heat stress and cutting evaporation. Some crops yield more, few less. When you have plenty of crop land, you don't need them to pick up every last bit of sun; you have plenty of room, so they can be spread out. You could grow berries or cherry tomatoes under, whatever else you grow. They don't get so hot in fields, either, and the vertical mounting keeps dust off. And they produce revenue year-round. (Search: agrivoltaics) They also do well in pasture, where the livestock keep the weeds down. On some crops, you want them horizontal above the plants to protect from freak hailstorms, heavy downpour, and harsh noonday sun. We all like parking under solar panels in parking lots, where they keep the rain off on our way to the car, and keep it from getting too hot inside. And, they make roofs last longer; not just on houses, but on warehouses, factories, airport terminals, malls, what have you. Finally, deserts are usually a long way from where people want the power. There is absolutely no shortage of places to put solar panels where they will work better and longer, and do other good besides.
- iso1337 4y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plasma_deep_drilling_technology https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plasma_deep_drilling_technol... Plasma drilling sounds like it could be useful - the plasma essentially melts the material surrounding the borehole into a glass as it drills down.
- funcDropShadow 4y agoAround 10 years ago there was quite a lot of fuzz about geothermal heating for newly built houses in southern Germany. That slowed down after some towns experienced movement below the settlement because formerly water-proof sediments had been breached. Ground water was able to move in places it could not move before and that lead to movement of the ground below the settlement. And most houses are not build to move around.