4 ms·
Preventing plaque formation avoids the need to remove it. Actually accomplishing that seems unlikely, but not impossible.
by Retric 4y ago
Preventing plaque formation avoids the need to remove it.
Actually accomplishing that seems unlikely, but not impossible.
- klipt 4y agoA keto diet without sugar or starch should prevent most plaque formation, shouldn't it?
- Retric 4y agoNo, a balanced keto diet might be moderately better than a normal diet in terms of plaque, but even wild cats living on a nearly 100% meat diet still get dental plaque.
- trhway 4y agoreminded - our cat was flossing his teeth using the corn broom that we had. He would press the broom with his paw and would byte a fiber close to the broom root and would move his head away so that the fiber would be flossing the teeth, and he would repeat it multiple times flossing different teeth. Still had perfect teeth at 13 when the cancer took him.
- rhinoceraptor 4y agoThere has been work done is creating GM S. mutans that don't produce biofilms, and that would replace your native S. mutans. It could be done by just brushing your teeth with a toothbrush treated with the bacteria so it would cost pennies per treatment.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Retric 4y agoThat’s a long way from actually replacing brushing and flossing. For one thing, streptococcus sobrinus is more closely associated with cavity formation than streptococcus mutans. But more importantly these biofilms are a significant evolutionary advantage so this replacement is an unstable situation. Some positive benefits are likely, just don’t assume it can work alone.
- arrosenberg 4y agoBiofilms are an evolutionary advantage for the bacteria, not the host. Biofilms make the colony much, much harder to kill. How advantageous can it be to the host anyways, if 4 out of 5 dentists recommends obliterating it 2-3x a day?
- dataangel 4y agoThey may indirectly be an advantage for the host because if the bacteria aren't competitive they will get replaced by bacteria that are. The devil you know...
- arrosenberg 4y agoI hear you, but again - the strongly recommended medical advice is to brush your teeth twice a day to remove bacteria before they can form a biofilm, so if that was true, you would expect to see people who brush their teeth have worse problems from advantageous bacteria.
- Retric 4y agoThis is trying to replace the bacteria population not the host. It’s like trying to stop drug use by busting drug dealers. As long as the niche exists a city can’t stop and say we caught all the bad guys problem is solved.
- arrosenberg 4y agoThat analogy doesn't hold - the niche is still being filled. A better equivalent would be the synthol drink from Star Trek - it's the same bacteria, but modified to remove the most problematic part.
- Retric 4y agoIt’s the same relationship: We might call it the same species, but the relevant chararistic changed is detrimental to a [human] host but beneficial to the [bacteria] parasite. We might call it the same species, but the relevant chararistic changed is detrimental to a [city] host but beneficial to the [drug dealer] parasite. Consider if you removed all the wings on misquotes in a city. That would be useful on day 1, but not going to do anything a year from now. It’s the same species, but missing a very useful trait means it’s getting outcompeted.