3 ms·
> They would have all gone bankrupt or had to be rescued by the government But isn't the point to separate the investment banks away from the savings banks? Th
by mindslight 18y ago
> They would have all gone bankrupt or had to be rescued by the government
But isn't the point to separate the investment banks away from the savings banks? There's a fundamental type difference between a dollar earned and saved, and a promissory-based dollar conjured up by a debt instrument.
When an investment bank fails (as it should when it's made a bad mortal investment), the funny money dries up, leaving the holder high and dry. If this holder employed bad accounting (by counting promised dollars as dollars-in-hand), then they may fail as well (and so on). However, this should not continue into the institutions that hold the savings of the people who didn't want to play economic make-believe.
> Many foreign countries never had any law like Glass-Steagall in place and they don't seem to be suffering the same problems
How many other countries have currencies that are used as reserve by the rest of the world? (which greatly lengthens the time for consequence of inflationary policy to be felt)
- 0x44 18y agoIf this holder employed bad accounting (by counting promised dollars as dollars-in-hand), then they may fail as well (and so on). That's called accrual accounting, and is required by United States Generally Accepted Accounting Principles, International Financial Reporting Standards, and the UK's Companies Act.
- mindslight 18y agoWhat I mean is if the holder only employed such accounting. I can see how such figures are normally useful, but the abstraction can break down when you aren't paid (and in this case, did so catastrophically). If your investment bank wants to survive downturns, it should be factoring this possibility into its decisions.
- BrandonM 18y ago"However, this should not continue into the institutions that hold the savings of the people who didn't want to play economic make-believe." How are these savings going to provide any interest if they are not redistributed as loans? The whole point of a bank is to allow your money to work for you while also providing loan capital to those who have a good use for it. It's impossible to have a non-negative (due to administrative costs) savings account without loaning the money to someone. Or am I completely missing your point?
- mindslight 18y agoHome/business loans made by a savings bank are subject to the reserve requirements. If these loans turn out to be bad and cause bank insolvency, the amount isn't huge because we're dealing with first-order numbers mostly backed by collateral. When the FDIC steps in to repay depositors, no money is lost (besides the bank's investors).
- BrandonM 18y agoOkay, I hoped that's what you meant, and not that savings banks should not be allowed to invest or loan money at all.