3 ms·
Is there such thing as weak evidence?
by croes 4y ago
Is there such thing as weak evidence?
- jstanley 4y agoEvidence that irrefutably proves something is very strong evidence. Evidence that kind of points towards something, but inconclusively, is weak evidence. For example, if 100 witnesses saw the accused murder the victim, and they're all credible, and they tell corroborating stories, that's pretty strong evidence. If 1 person thinks he saw the accused murder the victim, from the other side of a car park, but he has bad eyesight anyway and it was dark and raining, then that's weak evidence. It's not nothing, it's still evidence, but it is weak.
- dalbasal 4y agoSort of.. at least there is in the scientific tradition. Your theory predicting reality is generally weak evidence. It opens your theory to invalidation if the prediction fails, but does not rule out hypothetical alternative theories that also make the same prediction.
- samatman 4y agoTheories aren't evidence at all, what could you mean by this?
- pessimizer 4y agoA particular theory is a glue potentially connecting some number of observations. The observations + theory are evidence. The reason that a messy pool of blood on the floor is evidence of violence is the theory that the blood came out of a person in a messy way.
- golergka 4y agoIf you're bayesian.
- rootsudo 4y agoWouldn't that mean the quantity vs quality of conspiracies though?
- samatman 4y agoThis seems to be equivalent to asking if there is any such thing as strength of evidence at all, and so yes, of course. The evidence that 100mg of cyanide will kill you is very strong, the evidence that seed oils cause inflammation is weak, even though there's a lot of it.