4 ms·
Not my circus, not my monkeys. I don't think I can be held morally responsible for inaction in any circumstance. We didn't start the fire etc. I answered "no
by sneak 4y ago
Not my circus, not my monkeys. I don't think I can be held morally responsible for inaction in any circumstance. We didn't start the fire etc.
I answered "no pull" to every one except the one where the express goal was pranking the trolley driver (and no implied harm from pulling). This is apparently an unpopular opinion, but the only one I can reconcile with my own concept of responsibility.
- galangalalgol 4y agoInteresting! Do you disagree with the legal traditions that penalize doctors for failure to render aid, even when not at work? Or perhaps that isvlike saying you are actually the (or at least a) trolley switch operator, you just aren't in duty, in which case maybe your position obligates action when it is warranted?
- sneak 4y agoPrecisely. I am generally against compelled action of any kind, as it violates mutual consent, a fundamental principle I hold. A trolley switch operator has explicitly opted in to the responsibility, and consents to same. A bystander has not. This is why the famous internet video of the trolley problem acted out in the real world was required to offer post-experiment psychological counseling to the test subjects. They had not consented to being placed in a position of responsibility for life safety.
- mikkergp 4y ago> compelled action of any kind, as it violates mutual consent. So many of these questions are artificial, and it’s interesting how the legal system gets involved, but to a certain extent I think these questions are meant to describe a persons moral position outside of societies judgement of them. In many of these situations, it’s life and randomness that is putting these people into those situation, not producers of internet videos. I guess if you don’t feel bad your not morally responsible, but if someone was in distress I would feel _compelled_ to act. I assume by compelled you mean by human forces but I can’t help but compare it to the notion that chance and ‘destiny’ often violate our consent, and compell us to action.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoI used to think like you until I learned about how ethical frameworks are different when you are being extorted. This trolley problem is a class of extortion because your choices are very limited and out of your control. For example, it wouldn’t be wrong if someone forced you to steal a package of bubblegum or else they would kill your family and you decided to steal the bubblegum instead of inaction. In this case, it’s better to think of it as the act of saving your family and the extortionist caused the gum to be stolen. Every day people go through this type of extortion-limited choice when, for example, a couple experiences an ectopic pregnancy where inaction would result in the death of the mother. You aren’t primarily choosing to kill your child, you are choosing to save your wife.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sneak 4y agoThat seems to assume that the action to save the mother is the assumed preferred outcome, and the one that would be chosen? I am saying that it isn't wrong to choose inaction, either.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoIt’s true it’s context dependent. E.g. the mother may only have 1 day of life remaining for other reasons, in which case saving the child might be preferred.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Sohcahtoa82 4y agoIn the case of ectopic pregnancy, choosing inaction is absolutely wrong in every possible way. Inaction means both mother and fetus die. Action means just the fetus dies. I don't see how you could possibly defend inaction. The fetus is going to die either way.
- 4y ago
- hyper_reality 4y agoTo pick an extreme but well-known thought experiment. You are walking past a pond, and see a child drowning in it. You glance around and there is nobody else nearby. You could easily jump in and save the child. It will certainly die if you do not. If you choose to do nothing and ignore the drowning child, are you really not morally responsible in any way for the child's death?
- stavros 4y agoIf you are morally responsible for the child's death, you are morally responsible for basically every evil in the world right now, since you didn't do everything in your power to prevent all of them. You may say that that is the case, but if you're responsible for everything, you may as well be responsible for nothing.
- ParetoOptimal 4y ago> If you are morally responsible for the child's death, you are morally responsible for basically every evil in the world right now No, you are morally responsible for every evil happening right in front of you that you could immediately change with little risk to yourself. For instance if you can't swim and the child is in the middle of the pond, I'd argue you aren't responsible because the risk is too great to yourself. In fact due to the danger of drowning people pulling you under, I'd argue unless the child is in water shallow enough for you to stand in it's not your moral responsibility to save them. Though in the situation, I'd probably feel compelled to save them anyway.
- stavros 4y ago> No, you are morally responsible for every evil happening right in front of you that you could immediately change with little risk to yourself. The problem with this is that you snuck a quantitative difference there and made it sound qualitative. How much risk is "little risk"? What if you could spend all your money and save N people from starvation? There's no risk to you, so are you responsible for their deaths if you don't do it? What if the child is a bit less likely to pull you under? What if even less than that? Where do you draw the line? You're never completely free of responsibility, there are just varying degrees.
- tshaddox 4y agoIs it conceivable for you to be placed in a situation where there is no "privileged default"? In other words, a situation where you must choose between two options and there is no option that you can somehow point to as the "no, I refuse to choose" option?