2 ms·
> At the end of the day, the worst part is that we talk about "science" as if it's some kind of anthropomophic creature with desires and feelings and a plan for
by woodruffw 4y ago
> At the end of the day, the worst part is that we talk about "science" as if it's some kind of anthropomophic creature with desires and feelings and a plan for us all. It's a uniquely modern flaw to say things like, "Science tells us that..." "Science is about.." "Science is against..." Does this not strike anyone else as creepy?
This, like so many other reactionary screeds, is based on an intentional misunderstanding: nobody is actually anthropomorphizing science. English doesn't have many elegant ways to say "a process provides inductive evidence for a claim"; that is all anyone is ever really saying when they attempt to reduce a hypothesis to a pop factoid.
Similarly for factuality itself: the post's author is arguing against an 8th grader's understanding of "fact vs. fiction." It's simply not how either scientists (or the serious scientific press) uses it. Strip that away, and this is just a confused ramble about pop culture, everybody's favorite thing to hate.
- HKH2 4y ago> English doesn't have many elegant ways to say "a process provides inductive evidence for a claim"; that is all anyone is ever really saying when they attempt to reduce a hypothesis to a pop factoid. Then why not say 'the scientific method' so that we know you don't mean 'scientists'?
- smegsicle 4y ago> nobody is actually anthropomorphizing science for one thing, a few years ago there was an irritating practice of any perspective outside current academic dogma being described as 'anti-science' that is to say, the simplistic anthropomorphizing of science was leveraged in order to try to change the word 'science' to instead mean 'our chosen narrative', a position which is itself anti-science in the most meaningful way