4 ms·
> <50% want to do the necessary ground-work of "cutting Wyoming down to 0.2 senators". No, that's not the case. I'd dare say >50% of the population wants to c
by cogman10 4y ago
> <50% want to do the necessary ground-work of "cutting Wyoming down to 0.2 senators".
No, that's not the case. I'd dare say >50% of the population wants to cut Wyoming down to 0.2 senators. But how do they accomplish that? The only viable route is a constitutional amendment. For that to pass, you need 2/3s of the senate to agree AND you need 3/4s of the states to ratify.
By saying "oh, well the majority can just insist on the change" ignores the fact that the current system gives the minority power to say no.
The only hard work the majority could actually do is move from these high population states into low population states to re-balance the voting power.
The US is not a democracy. 50% of the population wanting something means nothing. And without an actual civil war and new constitution, that won't change.
- rascul 4y ago> The US is not a democracy. It's a representative democracy, not a direct democracy.
- heartbeats 4y agoGrant this, but at some point, there's still a lack of majority support somewhere. >50% might support cutting Wyoming down to size, but <50% support removing the supermajority requirement for constitutional amendment.
- cogman10 4y agoWhat does that matter? Even if I granted that, the only way to change the supermajority requirement IS a constitutional amendment, requiring a supermajority. There is no state where you can blame the government not working based on the simple majority not trying hard enough (Barring a revolution).