He quoted 3 sentences from the Wikipedia article, in addition to his own. All of which are relevant and valid points. You didn’t address any of those. Neither

He quoted 3 sentences from the Wikipedia article, in addition to his own. All of which are relevant and valid points. You didn’t address any of those. Neither did you address his own. Even if it was only one, reasserting the author thesis, pretending to ask why he is dismissive while ignoring everything he brought is not a constructive contribution. It’s manipulative at best.