4 ms·
> don't know, I think your frustration may be a little misplaced. This recent tide in American culture of being on tippy-toes (limited as it may be to the liber
by rayiner 4y ago
> don't know, I think your frustration may be a little misplaced. This recent tide in American culture of being on tippy-toes (limited as it may be to the liberals and closed circles in academia), I don't find it appalling, I find it... silly, if not admirable, because I understand it's coming from a good place.
You’re missing the point. I’m not talking about white people being helpful or “encouraging.” I’m talking about white people claiming the power to decide what is good for minorities and who gets to define the identity of those minorities and how they relate to society as a whole? To use a specific example: It’s not about whether calling Hispanics “Latinx” is a good idea or not. It’s about “who gets to decide what we call Hispanics?”
And on that front, university wokeness is not “coming from a good place.” “Latinx” happened because white liberals used their institutional power to adopt a label for Latinos that reflected the intersectional value system of liberal whites. They co-opted the power of the community to decide for themselves even the simple question of how they are identified.
Musa Al-Gharbi’s analysis hits the nail on the head: “White elites —who play an outsized role in defining racism in academia, the media, and the broader culture — instead seem to define ‘racism’ in ways that are congenial to their own preferences and priorities. Rather than actually dismantling white supremacy or meaningfully empowering people of color, efforts often seem to be oriented towards consolidating social and cultural capital in the hands of the ‘good’ whites.” (See: https://contexts.org/blog/who-gets-to-define-whats-racist/ https://contexts.org/blog/who-gets-to-define-whats-racist/)
You see this on issue after issue: policing, gender norms, religion, etc.
> The worst that happens when someone says Latinx is they might looks silly, a reasonable trade I'd say given the stakes.
Wrong. When someone says Latinx, they are imposing white liberal notions of Latino identity on Latinos.
> I think you and I have been through this in the past, but: the jury is out on this one, folks of a certain race were systemically oppressed for generations and as a result they are at the bottom of the barrel in terms of house-ownership, savings, etc. To not make the slightest of effort to undo the actions of this extant government is a ludicrous idea.
Respectfully, who cares what you think? I’m not saying that to be glib, but to get to the fundamental question: who gets to decide what’s good for minorities?
Any effort to address the consequences of discrimination has trade offs. White liberals don’t have to live with the social and economic consequences of those policies. It’s completely indefensible to argue that white elites should be able to overrule the views of minorities themselves on those questions.
> When I see an educated person argue against this, I see it as a mark on their morals.
When I see a person argue in favor of white elites choosing how society should relate to a minority group—against the majority opinion of people in that minority group—I consider it a mark on their morals. Such people consider minorities as mere subjects on which to apply their own ideological notions, and that’s morally wrong.
- pen2l 4y ago> to get to the fundamental question: who gets to decide what’s good for minorities? Progressive white elites. I'm only half joking, hear me out: support for same-sex marriage shot up from being a minority position to a majority position only recently in our lifetime: https://datawrapper.dwcdn.net/PyDKd/3/ https://datawrapper.dwcdn.net/PyDKd/3/ Even Obama wouldn't give a straight answer on this early on in his presidency until Biden forced his hand on it. So there was a lot of debate, a lot of wrangling, I think it's even fair to say that the progressive hetero white elites were at the forefront and leading the charge on this issue, and they ended up convincing society that same-sex couples should have a right to marry and now this right is here to stay (well, maybe), with an overwhelming majority support from Americans. You and I both come from a place where same-sex marriage still isn't legal. There may be few lone progressive voices in Pakistan and Bangladesh that are going against the grain, and one hopes that overtime they succeed in making a dent and a readjustment of values is made in due time. If it was a question of values, the white elites had better values on that one. But application of values on the issue of languages being made gender-neutral is not as clear-cut an issue as same-sex marriage and the stakes are not as high, and frankly I'm not extremely resolute in the position I take of preferring gender-neutrality in everyday language. I want to draw your attention to the paragraph above the one you pasted in which Musa Al-Gharbi says: > [whites] neglect to actually listen to ordinary black or brown folk about what they find offensive, or what their racial priorities are. You're a brown person like me. I don't know if you're still hanging out with brown people in America, but you probably know how incredibly pervasive racism against blacks and hispanics is in this crowd behind closed doors, hell half the lot of them are still clinging to their caste systems so no thank you, I rather prefer to not hear the racial priorities of brown people, I don't want that trojan horse snuck inside America. While some ideas are still in incubation, like the one about gender-neutrality in languages, you are as right as I am at this point; I think our society hasn't settled on the issue. But wouldn't you agree that it shouldn't _just_ be the latinoes and latinas that get to decide on this issue because we're talking about gender-neutrality in American English, others get to have a say in this too because to some degree all immigrants are obliged to integrate to American values and customs. I'm often right there with you when you decry loss of religion and community in American culture, and I put the rampant homelessness in Seattle and San Francisco (indeed some of the most liberal places) squarely on the feet of elite liberals and the housing policies they mainly get to control, so it's not like I'm totally succumbing the floor to progressive liberals and their every whim. But still I posit that western progressivism has a little bit of a leg up on the questions of values, they lead the way with the Enlightenment, there was great nuance in what they offered and they were open to listening to reasoned disagreement, they lead the way with interracial marriage, same-sex marriage, and while the jury is not out on gender-neutral language, I mostly like what they have to say. > Any effort to address the consequences of discrimination has trade offs. White liberals don’t have to live with the social and economic consequences of those policies. It’s completely indefensible to argue that white elites should be able to overrule the views of minorities themselves on those questions. I think we're conflating categories. Broadly speaking, the white academics I think are in the green and their motives are probably fine. White elites, for example in tech, are not on the same side as white academics on the more important and decisive issues like housing -- they are the ones screwing things up for everyone.