5 ms·
Unraveling the linothorax mystery, or how linen armor came to dominate our lives (2013)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 4y ago> Alicia Aldrete is coauthor, with Gregory S. Aldrete and Scott Bartell, of Reconstructing Ancient Linen Body Armor: Unraveling the Linothorax Mystery. The website of the University of Wisconsin–Green Bay’s Linothorax Project contains more behind-the-scenes information on this unparalleled effort, including an eight-minute mini-documentary and additional images. As an aside, Gregory Aldrete has a bunch of courses on Audible under “Great Courses”. (You can also get them from The Teaching Company now call Wondrium). I heartily recommend that you listen to them if you are at all interested in ancient history.
- jcoq 4y agoI came here to say the same exact thing! These courses are excellent. As a follow-up to those courses, there are also some courses about the middle ages by Philip Daileader that pick-up the story at the decline of the Western empire. (Also, I'm deriving great value from the Wondrium app).
- Geonode 4y agoIn a lot of composites, the titular material isn't the main material. It's almost always glue instead. Which is fine, but one of the drawbacks is the thing is usually heavier and stiffer than you would imagine. Here it's rabbit glue, which is probably a type of hide glue?
- dang 4y agoRelated: Unraveling the linothorax mystery (2013) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24129519 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24129519 - Aug 2020 (42 comments)
- Simon_O_Rourke 4y agoI remember Terry Jones doing some slapstick documentary on the First Crusade, and described how some footsoldiers wearing padded "armor", would be seen with multiple arrows sticking out of the armor in battle, and still fighting. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gambeson https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gambeson
- debacle 4y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fzWipvLiCjY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fzWipvLiCjY Todd's Workshop is a great channel for exploring these technologies.
- toss1 4y agoWorking in high-performance composites, this is fantastic work! It never ceases to amaze me how some of the oldest technology was composites, and how much we can do with even basic materials - it doesn't have to be carbon fiber and epoxy to get great results, in this case linen and rabbit glue makes really effective and lightweight armor. Sort of related, the Mongol's archery bows from Genghis Khan's time were also amazing pieces of engineering available materials into high-performing tools.
- klyrs 4y agoAs cool as this is, the historicity is questionable. > But Peter Connolly's reconstruction was based on a mis-remembered, twice-translated summary of a Byzantine chronicle which did not mention glue, not on an ancient text, artefact, or depiction https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linothorax https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linothorax
- toss1 4y agoInteresting - doesn't disprove it, but certainly makes it at best a very flimsy basis and a long conjecture. I wonder if there were any other things made with such composites of binder and fibers or fabric, or if this is really a long shot in the dark
- throwawaylinux 4y agoNot fabric or clothing, but composite bows have been around over 3000 years (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Composite_bow https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Composite_bow), and make really long shots in the dark.
- tristor 4y agoThere is a comment from the author in response to someone that I found fascinating, and I am quoting here to respond to: > We found that even more of a threat than rain was one’s own sweat on a hot day. So, yes, it does need waterproofing, both inside and out. We did a number of experiments along those lines, and found that rubbing a block of beeswax over all sides of the armor provided nice waterproofing. It also makes the armor smell nice! When you wear it for a couple hours, your own body heat softens the glue a bit and makes it conform to your body shape, so it is much more comfortable to wear than rigid types of armor. Our reconstructions weighed about 10 pounds–about one third the weight of bronze armor that would provide the same degree of protection. Thanks for the questions! It would explain to some degree why this armor may have found such military success during that time period, that it was more comfortably and more closely conformed to the body while offering similar protections. One of the things many people who've never had to wear armor for an extended period of time on a hot day don't realize is how horribly uncomfortable armor is, and how that discomfort can be a severe distraction under battlefield conditions. One thing that also interested me about this is that we found that one of the strongest materials we have available to use in modern materials science is also laminated cloth, in this case carbon fiber laminates. By ensuring that the direction of the weaves are perpendicular to one another when doing a cloth layup, and using a sufficiently strong adhesive/sealant, these types of materials are incredibly strong. Carbon fiber and carbon kevlar both are exceptionally strong materials that would make great armor (and do), and it seems the linothorax is essentially an early application of some of the same ideas, with lesser source materials.
- kbenson 4y ago> By ensuring that the direction of the weaves are perpendicular to one another when doing a cloth layup, and using a sufficiently strong adhesive/sealant, these types of materials are incredibly strong. I wonder if they tested that when creating their replica linen armor? That seems like the kind of thing ancient armor makers would definitely have tested out.
- sillyquiet 4y ago>One of the things many people who've never had to wear armor for an extended period of time on a hot day don't realize is how horribly uncomfortable armor is, and how that discomfort can be a severe distraction under battlefield conditions. Maybe! A well tailored and properly weight-distributed mail hauberk (which is also conformal) is surprisingly comfortable for extended period of time in all kinds of weather. (Source: my own experience in medieval re-enactment). What gets you in hot weather are the textiles - with mail its the necessary padding under the mail that will cause issues in hot weather. the author's point that linen was more comfortable than 'rigid' armor was probably true, but I will point out that rigid armors were also individually tailored, balanced, and created for optimal weight distribution. As an aside mail armor was a successful and popular armor for a millennium, from the Iron Age to the middle ages (and continued to be successful as an augment to plate and in other contexts like South Asia and India until probably the 16th century). It was probably contemporary to the linen armor of the article (In time, not geographically - it was used most heavily in iron-rich regions in central Europe at first).
- 99_00 4y agoIt's good to hear about this. I still remember hearing about it a decade ago https://www.nbcnews.com/id/wbna34810209 https://www.nbcnews.com/id/wbna34810209 Our view of history is based on what has survived, metal, stone, clay, some papers that have been copied or existed in dry climate. Anything that can rot and hasn't been reproduced, and was in a wet climate will be lost and removed from the picture we create of history.
- kurupt213 4y agoThat’s why the texts that do survive are so important. They give us descriptions of the transient experience that doesn’t make it into the archeological record. Analytical instrumentation has made an incredible jump in sensitivity in the last 10 years. Molecular paleontologists can detect fossilized protein and nucleic acid fragments in remains that are millions of years old. I think we there is going to be a complete change in how archeologists do surveys of more modern historical sights. The molecular fingerprints left in the human record should be much more significant. Maybe they’ll find evidence of parchment in burials showing writing goes back way further than we currently think
- TheMagicHorsey 4y agoThe manufacturing process seems very like an ancient version of how modern carbon fiber armor is built.
- Vecr 4y agoDo people really use carbon fiber in armor? I know the Army tried glass fiber and Kevlar for helmets before choosing Kevlar (and now some UHMWPE as well), but I can't remember anything about carbon fiber. I know you can buy carbon fiber helmets and part carbon fiber part Kevlar and/or UHMWPE helmets (at least in theory, there are problems with massive (multi year!) lead times and MIL/LE only items), but they always had dubious protection from ballistic projectiles, regarding back-face deformation, splintering, cracking, spalling, pass-through, etc.
- TheMagicHorsey 4y agoIt is used to build protective armor that motorcyclists wear. Not bulletproof armor.
- zeristor 4y agoA lovely little video about growing, and processing Flax to make linen: https://youtu.be/TFuj7sXVnIU https://youtu.be/TFuj7sXVnIU
- worik 4y agoSilk has been used this way too, I believe. There may be some advantage in the relative softness too, relative to iron. When something bangs into it, it will not transmit all the shock through to the body but will absorb some by deforming.
- kayodelycaon 4y agoPlate armor and mail were typically worn over padding.
- kurupt213 4y agoThe kinetic energy still has to be dampened
- exhilaration 4y agoSilk used in bulletproof vests (1999, Thailand): http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/science/nature/379338.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/science/nature/379338.stm
- bsder 4y agoAs I understand it, one of the advantages of silk is that it wrapped around things such that you could remove the arrowhead without surgery. That's a really big deal for avoiding infection.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jacobr1 4y agoI first encountered the idea in fiction a few months ago reading "Sixteen Ways to Defend a Walled City" [1]. For those interested in this kind of thing, it is a fictional mashup of a variety of technical innovations when an engineer (the army core kind) is the highest ranking military officer left during a siege. [1] https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/37946419-sixteen-ways-to-defend-a-walled-city https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/37946419-sixteen-ways-to...
- dredmorbius 4y agoNB: Army corps. (Pronounced as "core".)
- pixodaros 4y agoThe Green Bay Team reproduced a type of armour which nobody can show was made before 1970. The glue in their linen armour comes from a bad translation of a hasty summary of a medieval Roman chronicle https://www.joshobrouwers.com/articles/glued-linen-armour/ https://www.joshobrouwers.com/articles/glued-linen-armour/
- BXLE_1-1-BitIs1 4y agoComposite layups in aircraft often rotate layers 45° from the previous layer.
- moron4hire 4y agoAccording to this paper, the idea that linothorax was made from glued layers is probably due to a mistranslation. https://utpjournals.press/doi/10.3138/mous.17.3.003 https://utpjournals.press/doi/10.3138/mous.17.3.003 But this paper came out 7 years after OP.
- trhway 4y agoI read somewhere that such simple armor was supposedly made by having the sewn together linen layers placed in a basin in the expected shape and pouring sea water and letting it dry in the Sun over and over again.
- msrenee 4y agoDo they discuss the draw weight of the bow or any measurements they made to determine that the weapons were imparting the same damage as would have been common historically? It takes a while to work up to the sort of draw weight that was common in trained archers. I'm not just talking about longbows. A 90 lb recurve isn't something you just pick up one day.
- kurupt213 4y agoIt’s worth reading the main paper
- bondolo 4y agoI loved the sentence: "We also found out that linen stiffened with rabbit glue strikes dogs as in irresistibly tasty rabbit-flavored chew toy, and that our Labrador retriever should not be left alone with our research project."
- jiggawatts 4y agoThe WikiPedia article lists some criticisms of the "glued layers" theory: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linothorax#Research https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linothorax#Research > The project received considerable media attention after Aldrete tested his construction by shooting an arrow at Bartell with cameras rolling. But Peter Connolly's reconstruction was based on a mis-remembered, twice-translated summary of a Byzantine chronicle which did not mention glue, not on an ancient text, artefact, or depiction. No culture before the 20th century is known to have made linen armour in this way.
- rsynnott 4y agoOh, the exclusive our. I thought they meant that linen armor dominated the lives of people in general, which seemed improbable.