3 ms·
There are several things wrong with this line of thinking. The first error is that telling someone that words don't hurt doesn't automatically create an indepen
by kelseyfrog 4y ago
There are several things wrong with this line of thinking. The first error is that telling someone that words don't hurt doesn't automatically create an independent sense of self worth in someone. Instead it teaches people to not share pain caused by words. To some people, this has the appearance of working - namely it isn't brought up again, but it does nothing to solve the problem of the experience of pain people feel.
The second is an error in generalization that may very well apply to people who do have this skill, but has disastrous consequences for those that don't. The people who experience live this way would do well to understand the type of person they are giving such advice to before they assume that everyone experiences the world as they do.
As someone at the receiving end of advice like this. It doesn't help. What ends up ensuing follows a similar pattern to all patterns based on individuating ideologies - the person isn't doing it right, or didn't try hard enough. People learn to not express their feelings instead.
Lastly, making a distinction between objective and subjective pain is trying to carve out phenomenological categories that simply don't exist.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoCopying from other comments... Sticks and stones is not a full instruction set, but an introduction to the concept and a reminder. It is not, and should not be considered "one simple trick" to deal with hurtful words. This doesn't mean that it is useless or detrimental. It is a reminder that self-esteem should not be based on the opinions of others. More clearly needs to be done to instill baseline self-esteem. That doesn't mean it's not a helpful reminder of the concept when one encounters derogatory feedback. It is like saying: "When someone says something that makes you feel bad, remember the conversations we had about how just because someone says something, it doesn't mean it is true. People will say things to try to hurt you, but they are just being mean and it isn't true. It reflects on them as a person, not you as a person. However, if someone physically hurts you, this is different." In my mind, "sticks & stones" is the same thing, but shorter and more memorable.
- kelseyfrog 4y agoI'm getting the sense that this is a conversation between a neurotypical person and a neurodivergent person and that is the source of the disconnect between our understandings.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoCan you explain more of what you mean? Are you talking about my example of talking to a child or implying that I am neurodivergent. If the former, It is an interesting thought. In many ways children can be seen as very similar neurodivergent adults. In some cases this is because they simply lack basic information adults take for granted. In others, they simply don't have the "software" to process it yet. If the latter, that's a bit rude.
- kelseyfrog 4y agoI'm assuming you're neurotypical and that represents a gulf between our understanding of the subjective mental machinery between ourselves.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI see, that makes more sense than is probably the more charitable reading I should have taken. I agree that my perspective isn't Universal and therefore doesn't apply to everyone, but I don't think that is a prerequisite for being good advice in the general sense. The concept of understanding and preempting emotional responses is a fundamental Concept in cognitive behavioral therapy and typical emotional growth. Typical individuals have the ability to modify their emotional response with training and practice . The idea is not to suppress an emotion but not have the reaction in the first place. For example, anger management might teach someone not to feel so angry when they encounter traffic. Instead of entering a escalating feedback loop of anger, they might rationalize it as impersonal and continue their Drive without the unpleasant emotions.