4 ms·
> I am fully in favor of legalized abortion, but why was it never codified in law? The US constitution made leeway for rights to be unenumerated, or not explic
by cogman10 4y ago
> I am fully in favor of legalized abortion, but why was it never codified in law?
The US constitution made leeway for rights to be unenumerated, or not explicitly spelled out (9th amendment [1])
Up until this current supreme court, a right has never been removed. That was not standard jurisprudence.
Now, however, we have radicals on the court who take the view that "if it's not in the text, it isn't protected" completely ignoring the 9th amendment and often only applying it when they favor the text ideologically (see: gun laws. Plenty of historical documents show that the 2nd amendment was about states being able to form militias and not arming individuals. It literally wasn't until about the 1990s that lobbying from the NRA successfully reinterpreted the amendment to mean "everyone gets a gun").
The next problem is that in order to pass new laws, you need to have a super-majority in the senate, a majority in the house, and the presidency to go along with the law. Pretty difficult when the republican party has decided they want absolutely no new laws and certainly no expansion of rights. (See: how hard they are fighting against the HR-1 the voter rights act [2])
But, of course, while abortion rights are wildly popular (~80% of the population supports them in some circumstances. ~50% in all circumstances [3]), we don't run the country as a democracy, but rather a representative republic. And that's the problem. While the people want this, the representatives do not. A combination of gerrymandering and voter suppression has angled them into a position where the population that elected them doesn't track with the general population.
This is exactly the same issue with climate change. 60% of the population view it as a dangerous problem and 40% of the population view it as overblown. [4] That 40% ends up with a larger portion of power in the senate because any action to realistically curtail climate change ends up being filibustered.
The issue america has is we have 1 party with the motto that "The scariest phrase is I'm from the government and I'm here to help" as such, they block any and all regulations and government actions they can feasibly stop. The setup of our government favors that strategy. Their voters don't CARE that they aren't passing laws, they prefer it that way. This kills the ability to compromise.
[1] https://www.law.cornell.edu/constitution/ninth_amendment https://www.law.cornell.edu/constitution/ninth_amendment
[2] https://cha.house.gov/hr-1-people-act https://cha.house.gov/hr-1-people-act
[3] https://news.gallup.com/poll/1576/abortion.aspx https://news.gallup.com/poll/1576/abortion.aspx
[4] https://news.gallup.com/poll/1615/environment.aspx https://news.gallup.com/poll/1615/environment.aspx
- heartbeats 4y ago> The next problem is that in order to pass new laws, you need to have a super-majority in the senate, a majority in the house, and the presidency to go along with the law. Pretty difficult when the republican party has decided they want absolutely no new laws and certainly no expansion of rights. (See: how hard they are fighting against the HR-1 the voter rights act [2]) Why isn't this abolished, then? Does a majority of the U.S. electorate actually want to abolish the filibuster and so on? If not, then it seems like a logical series of propositions: 1. A majority of the U.S. population want >60% majorities to pass laws. 2. A majority, but less than 60%, support nationally permitting abortion. 3. Therefore, while a majority of the U.S. support abortion, they don't support any system that would actually allow it to become law. "The federal government is hopelessly useless" and "the states shouldn't get to decide anything" seem to me like two contrary positions. Either: 1. The current federal system is fine, and there is no need to change anything. 2. The current federal system is not fine, but it can be changed. Therefore, it should simply be reformed. 3. The current federal system is not fine, but it can't be changed. Therefore, the states should have the power instead. What am I missing, here? Genuinely curious.
- cogman10 4y ago> What am I missing, here? Genuinely curious. Population distribution. There are 50 states in the US. Each state gets 2 senators. States with low populations (think, Wyoming) tend to lean republican while the few states with high populations tend to lean democrat. The end result is these rural states end up with a disproportionate level of voting power in the senate where the fillibuster exists. Were the US population evenly distributed then this wouldn't be as much as a problem. There's also been a massive shift in political attitude with the republicans. Back in the Clinton presidency, democrats and republicans often worked together on bills and compromises to keep the government functioning. This changed with the tea party and Newt Gingrich at the end of Clinton's presidency. After Clinton, Obama was the next democrat president. He had a filibuster proof majority briefly but lost it + the house for the rest of the presidency after the first half of his first term. He was still working on compromises with the republican party (unsuccessfully) and in his second term when he lost the senate it was simply too late to get anything done. Mitch McConnell launched the "we won't approve anything you want to do" policy. Now, with Biden as president, the senate is 50/50 R and D. 2 democrat senators have said "we will not eliminate or change the filibuster under any circumstance" and that's where we currently sit. Democrats do not have the votes to move anything. It's not really hopeless. Assuming democrats turn out in the midterm to vote for democrat senators (we just need 2 more) then a lot of positive changes can happen. However, if instead they take the "nothing we do matters" approach then we are boned probably for the next 2 years and maybe even longer still. What's really distressing is republicans are now deciding that "any election that doesn't result in us winning was stolen" and they are putting into place laws to allow them to decide that "We don't think the people voted right or the democrats cheated" so they can effectively steal elections. We are heading head first into tyranny. I can't stress enough how important it is to vote for democrats in the upcoming elections. I get that people don't like them in many issues, but america is currently facing a take over by a party that has turned fascist.