4 ms·
From previous comments on the subject I gathered that farmers had apparently been exempted from or allowed to skirt many of the previous rules and regulations a
by masklinn 4y ago
From previous comments on the subject I gathered that farmers had apparently been exempted from or allowed to skirt many of the previous rules and regulations as well, despite a major if not the main source of pollution in the country.
But not this time, this time they're asked to put in the work same as everyone else, and that makes them very unhappy.
- ALittleLight 4y ago"Put in the work same as everyone else" seems, potentially, a bit off to me. Farming, by its nature, may involve more pollution than other professions. For example, a programmer working remotely emits very little nitrogen relative to a farmer, but it would be odd to say that the programmer is putting in the work on nitrogen emissions.
- jcranmer 4y agoThe general tenor of a lot of agricultural objections to these kinds of scenarios tends to be along the lines of "everyone else must fully eliminate all of their emission scenarios before we are forced to reduce a single thing." You can see a similar effect in the US's Western megadrought crisis, where farmers are adamant that all possible water use reduction in urban and suburban areas are done before you start discussing reducing the water use that goes to agriculture. And I've also seen some similar stories about Chesapeake Bay nitrogen runoff--fix all urban uses before you ask farmers to make changes to their fields.
- swader999 4y agoWater rights are more tied to the land and deeded as such. I don't think you want to bring water into the fray...
- z9znz 4y agoLet's take your analogy and fix it a bit. There's a guy living on one side of the lake in an area where electricity is cheap. He decides to setup a bitcoin miner in his home. Once he starts making money, he realizes his profit is quite good; so he scales up, and scales up, and scales up. Eventually he's drawing so much electricity that it's affecting the whole region; and he's cooling his mining rigs with circulated lake water, eventually affecting the local wildlife in the water and around it. Is that ok? After all, 1 rig was fine. What's wrong with 1000 rigs? What's wrong is that there was always an environmental or public cost that was not borne by the person making the profit. When it was a small cost, it wasn't a problem. But now it's a huge cost.
- ALittleLight 4y agoWhat I wrote was not an analogy but an example meant literally. It's specious to say that "we all follow a regulation" as some kind of argument by solidarity if the regulation is burdensome to some people and not to others.
- z9znz 4y agoThe LACK of regulation is burdensome to everyone. The farmers have increased profits at the expense of everyone else. If a person ran a small mail order business out of their house, and once a day a delivery vehicle came to drop off and pick up items, it wouldn't be much of an issue for the neighbors. Perhaps there wouldn't be any zoning regulations (because heretofore it was not necessary). But if the house is now full of workers, and there are a dozen semi trucks stopped in front of the house every day, the neighbors are going to be unhappy. Probably the local government will institute some zoning laws which prohibit that scale of operation in a residential area. Obviously that new regulation is burdensome to the person who was running a fine, profitable operation out of a residential home. Naturally they will fight to prevent such regulation. What we have here is a town where every block has such an operation. So the town has a lot of good production and export, and there's great financial incentive to continue. But not only are the locals who are not in that business impacted negatively by the businesses, but now even the neighboring towns are complaining about the torn up country roads (too many heavy trucks), the congested intersections, and so on. The businesses say the problem is not them, but lack of good infrastructure. Build more big roads and this won't be a problem. Why take away our successful businesses that we built with our own hands? Let us buy our neighbors houses (to expand our business), and those people can move away where they won't be bothered by us. Make no mistake - if it were possible, the farmers would buy up every piece of land in this small country and push all the other people out. Why stop with what you have when you could scale up and earn more?
- jeroenhd 4y agoThey haven't been exempted per se, but the license system the government implemented was way too loose and allowed for much more pollution than EU standards allow for. As an industry, they're disproportionately hit because they're disproportionately causing pollution of this type. In a European context, they've had an advantage over other countries for years. However, certain industries are subsidised less than their competition. Dairy production, for example, only takes 20% of their income from subsidies in the Netherlands, where competing countries provide double that. There is also pressure from the supermarket monopoly chain to keep prices incredibly low, as importing the same products from countries with lower wages is quite cheap in comparison. It's quite difficult to compete with much cheaper countries within the eurozone while staying within the pollution limits because there's simply less land to go around and more money needs to be spent on utilities, fuel, housing, and everything else. Clearly, violent protests to end pollution restrictions won't solve that problem, because of the Dutch government ignores these rules, what's keeping the foreign industry from doing the same and dropping prices even further? This can only end one way, and that's with fewer farms and less livestock within the Netherlands. I don't see what refusing to accept that is even still doing for these people.
- rocqua 4y agoThey asked for permits, they got permits. These permits were based on calculations of other measures the government was going to take to reduce nitrogen emissions. Now those permits turn out to be wrong, and whilst farmers with permits can keep them, they cannot sell, expand, or modify their business. Moreover, there is a chance they will be forced to sell their farms to the government. The government caused this problem, the only mistake farmers made was trusting the word of the government.