3 ms·
> Couldn't 800 actual humans have interacted with our elders instead of 800 robots with their money? Just a crazy idea, everyone. This is an amazingly out of t
by mindslight 4y ago
> Couldn't 800 actual humans have interacted with our elders instead of 800 robots with their money? Just a crazy idea, everyone.
This is an amazingly out of touch conclusion, and I've got to wonder if the author has any significant experience caring for elderly window(er)s. It is emotionally tiring work, that is ultimately never done. Because when you leave to take care of your own life, they go back to sitting around idle and the lonely time starts accumulating again. They all complain about the overwhelming silence [0].
About the best solution is hiring a helper for a few days a week, to come in with fresh energy, do that emotional labor, and let the elderly person self-actualize through their helper. But many elderly people who could afford to do so are still hesitent to, because they're set in their ways, and also depressed and don't see the point of doing anything.
The current de facto "solution" is lots of TV watching and becoming lost to the criminally malevolent "news" that tells them the world is falling apart. This increases their isolation, and also the work for others to interact with them. Any solution that enables elderly people to engage in interactive constructive dialog at their own speed is a massive step up, modulo the corporate dystopia malincentives.
[0] From my own experience it only takes around 2 weeks of being alone for me to start hallucinating human faces in inanimate objects, and I'm an introvert. Our brains are wired for social stimulation.
- joshlemer 4y agoIs it not possible to introduce these widows and widowers to each other to form new social groups in a self sustaining way?
- mindslight 4y agoIME, not really. They're set in their ways and patterns. To get any action out of an elderly person, caregivers have to put much more effort in. Their attitude basically boils down to "I don't need it", whether it is engaging with technology, leaving the house to see someone they already know, or anything that takes work (which is everything). Could a social network with real people be better than a "robot", while having similar activation energy? Perhaps. But the ultimate problem is a complete lack of self actualization due to complete disruption of their calcified patterns. So any technology is going to have to be very purpose-tailored, and still overtly pushed by caregivers. Faceboot and "senior centers" are for grey-haired young people.
- wswope 4y agoThanks for taking the time to write up your firsthand perspective! I was skeptical after reading the Smithsonian article (because hell if I’d personally want one of these robots in old age), but your explanation of their utility makes a lot of sense and fully changed my opinion.